"Circumventing mate choice is likely to have negative consequences for the genetics of a population," says Claus Wedekind of the University of Edinburgh in the UK in the October issue of Conservation Biology. "Males often are not equal with respect to genetic quality and female mate choice may be taking this into account."
Wedekind and two co-authors had previously shown that mate choice can increase the survival of young whitefish, which are bred in hatcheries. Like many fish species, during the breeding season male whitefish develop hundreds ornamental structures called breeding tubercles all over their bodies. Although these tiny, colorless tubercles may look insignificant, they are a powerful predictor of how well a male's young will survive: 12% more embryos survived a bacterial epidemic (Pseudomonas fluorescens) when their fathers had larger breeding tubercles (tubercle size ranged from about 50 to 400 microns).
Currently, most breeding programs for small populations focus on preserving genetic variation by minimizing inbreeding. Wedekind argues that as a population grows, managers should also start preserving genetic quality by incorporating mate choice into the breeding program. However, increasing genetic quality is likely to reduce genetic variation, which means managers will need to work out the optimal compromise between the two goals, he says.
Ways to incorporate mate choice into breeding programs include allowing: