HOME >> BIOLOGY >> NEWS
Essay on genes and behavior prompts culture clash in academic journal

Advocates of genetic determinism square off against two prominent Stanford University scientists in a lively and surprisingly acerbic debate over ''nature vs. nurture'' in the February issue of the journal Current Anthropology.

The often contentious dialogue, which fills 20 pages of the journal, revolves around a controversial essay titled ''Genes and Cultures: What Creates Our Behavioral Phenome?'' by Stanford biologists Paul R. Ehrlich and Marcus W. Feldman.

''A central theme of the flood of literature in recent years in 'evolutionary psychology' and 'behavioral genetics' is that much or even most human behavior has been programmed into the human genome by natural selection,'' Ehrlich and Feldman wrote. ''We show that this conclusion is without basis.''

The authors go on to provide a detailed critique of genetic determinism - a point of view popularized in recent years by MIT psychologist Stephen Pinker and others. In response, the editors of Current Anthropology printed a series of pro-and-con commentaries by researchers from eight institutions in the United States, Germany, Canada and Great Britain.

Of spiders and snakes

Members of Stanford's Department of Biological Sciences faculty, Ehrlich, the Bing Professor of Population Studies, and Feldman, the Burnet C. and Mildred Finley Wohlford Professor in the School of Humanities and Sciences, are considered pioneers in the fields of genetics and evolutionary biology. Ehrlich's latest book on the topic is Human Natures: Genes, Cultures and the Human Prospect. Feldman is co-author of the textbook Cultural Transmission and Evolution: A Quantitative Approach.

In their Current Anthropology essay, the authors noted that the general tendency among evolutionary psychologists is ''vastly to overestimate how much of human behavior is primarily traceable to biological universals that are reflected in our genes. One reason for this overestimation is the ease with which a l
'"/>

Contact: Mark Shwartz
mshwartz@stanford.edu
650-723-9296
Stanford University
23-Jan-2003


Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6

Related biology news :

1. Belgian researchers explore revolutionary approach to angiogenesis
2. Tracing genes, biologists show lizard migration is traced to Florida
3. Certain genes boost fish oils protection against breast cancer
4. Fossil genes reveal how life sheds form and function
5. Missing genes may help explain why plague bacteria are so deadly
6. Do genes respond to global warming?
7. Genetic map of important tree genes outlined
8. Mitochondrial genes cause nuclear mischief
9. Identifying tick genes could halt disease, bioterrorism threat
10. A genetic disorder yields insight into genes and cognition
11. Mouse study shows NPAS3 and NPAS1 genes may be linked to psychosis

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Essay genes and behavior prompts culture clash academic journal

(Date:11/18/2014)... Nov. 18, 2014  The Secure Identity & ... today jointly announce the formation of The Airport ... its Identity and Biometric Entry and Exit ... received official support from BORDERPOL, the international non-profit ... and provide expertise regarding border security, traveler and ...
(Date:11/15/2014)... , Nov. 13, 2014  While we may still ... Doctor McCoy used in "Star Trek" to gain instant access ... designed to work with smartphones and tablets for monitoring and ... the healthcare world. This may seem a tad Orwellian to ... to adopt some of these technological opportunities into their healthcare ...
(Date:11/7/2014)... led by Dr. Debra Auguste, associate professor, biomedical ... The City College of New York, have identified ... for one of the most aggressive forms of ... have a high mortality rate owing to aggressive ... therapeutic options. However, Professor Auguste,s team, discovered the ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Identity Management, Document Authentication and Biometric Companies Form "The Airport Entry and Exit Working Group", Releasing the Framework to Help Guide the Department of Homeland Security and Congress Towards Solutions 2Identity Management, Document Authentication and Biometric Companies Form "The Airport Entry and Exit Working Group", Releasing the Framework to Help Guide the Department of Homeland Security and Congress Towards Solutions 3Americans May Be Ready for a Brave New World of Healthcare 2Americans May Be Ready for a Brave New World of Healthcare 3Americans May Be Ready for a Brave New World of Healthcare 4
(Date:11/24/2014)... Belgium , Nov. 24, 2014 ... focused on developing diagnostic tests for cancer and other conditions, ... will be presented at the Science for Business BioWin Day ... Belgium . The data come from VolitionRx,s lung cancer ... Pneumology department of the Centre Hospitalier Universitaire (CHU) de Liege ...
(Date:11/24/2014)... Baltimore, MD (PRWEB) November 24, 2014 ... recruiting underrepresented patient populations into clinical trials at ... Maryland. , “Continental was created with the ... trials play a fundamental role in medical advances," ... the Tuskegee syphilis experiment to the immortal cell ...
(Date:11/24/2014)... , November 24, 2014 Senior ... honored for dynamic leadership skills, business acumen ... and medical information products and services, congratulates Diane ... Clinical Reference and Workflow, Elsevier Clinical Solutions, for being ... Watching ® Awards issue of Profiles in ...
(Date:11/22/2014)... November 21, 2014 Prominent academics, ... will gather on December 3rd at Genetic Rx, ... series. GeneticRx will take place at the Joseph ... and will discuss the present and future of ... skipping, and gene editing—as well as the treatment ...
Breaking Biology Technology:VolitionRx to Present Positive Data from Pilot Lung Cancer Study at BioWin Day 2014 2VolitionRx to Present Positive Data from Pilot Lung Cancer Study at BioWin Day 2014 3VolitionRx to Present Positive Data from Pilot Lung Cancer Study at BioWin Day 2014 4VolitionRx to Present Positive Data from Pilot Lung Cancer Study at BioWin Day 2014 5VolitionRx to Present Positive Data from Pilot Lung Cancer Study at BioWin Day 2014 6At Continental Clinical Solutions, CEO Saleh Stevens Focuses on Diversity in Clinical Trial Recruitment at Maryland Site 2At Continental Clinical Solutions, CEO Saleh Stevens Focuses on Diversity in Clinical Trial Recruitment at Maryland Site 3Elsevier Clinical Solutions' Diane Bartoli Featured In Profiles in Diversity Journal's 13th Annual Women Worth Watching Issue 2Elsevier Clinical Solutions' Diane Bartoli Featured In Profiles in Diversity Journal's 13th Annual Women Worth Watching Issue 3Pioneering Academics and Key Industry Leaders to Discuss Rare Diseases and the Emergence of New Genetic Medicines at Genetic Rx on December 3rd 2
Cached News: