False Security: You Can't Always Believe The Results Of A Genetic Test

Many laboratories offering genetic tests for cystic fibrosis don't test for enough mutations to give reliable results, according to a new study.

Last year, a panel convened by the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) recommended that prospective parents be routinely offered tests to see if they carry mutations that could give their children cystic fibrosis. This was the first time a genetic test had been recommended for the general population (This Week, 26 April 1997, p 12). The new findings, from a team of geneticists led by Wayne Grody of the University of California at Los Angeles, suggest that this recommendation was premature.

Cystic fibrosis, in which the lungs and airways become clogged with mucus and prone to infections, is caused by defects in a single large gene. There are hundreds of these mutations. Some are very rare, and certain mutations are more common in particular ethnic groups.

To be effective, the widespread screening urged by the NIH panel would have to test for many of the most common mutations. Exactly how many is still a matter of debate. "One thing that was conspicuously lacking from the panel's recommendation was how many mutations should be tested for," says Grody, who is co-chair of a committee drawing up guidelines on the issue for the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG). To identify 90 per cent or more of people carrying cystic fibrosis genes, it may be necessary to test for 20 of the most common mutations, Grody predicts.

Grody also leads a team of geneticists monitoring the testing labs on behalf of the ACMG and the College of American Pathologists. The team's latest survey, published in The American Journal of Human Genetics (vol 62, p 1252), reveals a disturbing picture. The investigators asked 45 labs how many mutations in the cystic fibrosis gene they usually test for. Forty-three responded, reporting numbers ranging from just one to 70. It was most co

Contact: Claire Bowles
Claire Bowles@rbi.co.uk
01 71 331-2751
New Scientist

Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Cant stand the pain? Your genes may be to blame
2. If You Cant Stop Polluting, Try Changing The Weather Instead
3. As A Carbon Sponge, Iron-Poor Coastal Waters Cant Always Do The Job, NaturePaper Shows
4. The Commons: Not Always A Tragedy
5. Once A Bully, Always A Bully, Invasive Non-Native Plants Tend To Be Aggressive Wherever They Find Themselves
6. Chemical Reaction Believed To Support Underground Microbes Is Now Unlikely
7. Results of pivotal study for GlaxoSmithKlines Valtrex published in New England Journal of Medicine
8. Results from open-label Raptiva study suggest continued benefit with long-term treatment
9. NASA Materials Conference Features Science Results, Experts on Technologies for Exploration
10. Abgenix Reports Encouraging Preclinical Results With ABX-EGF In Cancer Research
11. Encouraging Results In Preclinical Studies Of Parkinsons Disease Gene Therapy

Post Your Comments:

(Date:5/21/2019)... ... May 21, 2019 , ... If a ... know? How can we tell it apart from the millions of microorganisms that ... multi-institution research team, including Eric Young , assistant professor of chemical engineering ...
(Date:5/21/2019)... ... May 21, 2019 , ... Suvoda LLC , a SaaS ... management, has been named one of Inc. Magazine’s Best Workplaces for 2019, Inc.’s fourth ... now featured on Inc.com and hitting the newsstands on May 28, is the result ...
(Date:5/21/2019)... , ... May 20, 2019 , ... Dr. David ... acclaimed documentary. The documentary, Stem Cell Therapy: Biotechnology to the Rescue, was produced by ... long, Dr. Greene was interviewed in regards to the safety of the procedures along ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:4/18/2019)... (PRWEB) , ... April 18, 2019 , ... ... fuels, a research team that includes a chemical engineer at Worcester Polytechnic Institute ... microorganism that may make it possible to manufacture isobutanol and other biofuels more ...
(Date:4/16/2019)... , ... April 16, 2019 , ... ... systems, applications, and technology, today announced that Bank South Pacific (BSP), the largest ... RFP process. The bank awarded Fulcrum a contract to deliver a fingerprint-based Know ...
(Date:4/12/2019)... ... April 12, 2019 , ... An ... and will educate about innovative tools and devices being used to enhance cognitive ... more information. , This segment of Advancements will focus on Sound for Life, ...
(Date:4/10/2019)... ... 2019 , ... After more than three months of renovation, Lajollacooks4u is set ... updated appliances and modern lighting and fixtures, and will provide additional workspace for the ... tremendous growth in the demand for our team-building events and cooking classes over the ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
Cached News: