HOME >> BIOLOGY >> NEWS
Science historians ponder naming 'enemies' in science literature

In a perspective article published in the July 4, 2003 issue of the journal Science, Arizona State University biologists and historians of science Matthew Chew and Manfred Laubichler discuss a fundamental problem in the science of ecology its use of metaphorical language.

In the process, they are asking a question that has even greater consequences: can the way scientists communicate their findings warp or even dangerously mislead our perspective on science's meaning?

Chew and Laubichler argue that scientists' pervasive use of metaphors to encapsulate and express scientific ideas (for example, the use of literary metaphors such as "translation," "editing," "reading" for describing molecular processes), while necessary and powerful, also can carry with it the danger of adding false or misleading connotations to the concepts. The article, entitled "Natural Enemies Metaphor or Misconception?" focuses in particular on ecological science and its use of war and conflict metaphors to describe ecological dynamics involving introduced species.

In particular, the authors were struck by the pervasive and often casual use of the metaphorical phrase "natural enemies" to describe predator/prey and other similar inter-species ecological relationships. Though the metaphor is limited in its accuracy and carries with it unscientific connotations of conflict and antagonism, Laubichler notes that it is heavily used in ecological literature, often without explanation or definition.

"Though we didn't expect the term to be common, in the last four years we found about 60 references to 'natural enemies' in Science and Nature alone," Laubichler said. "It's a use of language that I find highly problematic. A scientist first uses 'natural enemies' as a metaphor for a particular ecological interaction but then it gets used in a different context and it doesn't take long for the idea to take hold that the category "natural enemy" actually exists out there in
'"/>

Contact: hathaway@asu.edu
Hathaway@asu.edu
480-965-6375
Arizona State University
3-Jul-2003


Page: 1 2 3

Related biology news :

1. A long-necked sea predator from China described in Science
2. Brown ecologist garners major National Science Foundation grant
3. Popular Science announces Third Annual Brilliant 10
4. Winner of 2004 EMBO Science Writing Prize announced
5. Study in Science reveals recreational fishing takes big bite of ocean catch
6. New paper in Science introduces revolutionary new paradigm for fishery management
7. Articles on forest fire risks published in BioScience
8. Ralph J. Cicerone nominated to be next National Academy of Sciences president
9. Canine word-learning research published in Science
10. Articles on remote sensing in ecology published in BioScience
11. Fostering Diversity in the Sciences Symposium

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Science historians ponder naming enemies science literature

(Date:7/23/2014)... around the world have no access to clean drinking ... million people die from water-related diseases every year. ETH ... a contribution to solving this problem. Working with researchers ... the Functional Materials Laboratory, the 23-year-old spent a year ... "What makes our DrinkPure filter unique is that you ...
(Date:7/23/2014)... Non-biting blow fly Chrysomya megacephala is commonly ... investigations to determine the time of death, referred to ... derived form of C. megacephala from Tamil ... morphological features and molecular characterization through generation of DNA ... in the open access Biodiversity Data Journal . ...
(Date:7/23/2014)... with ever-growing piles of electronic waste (or "e-waste"), scientists ... there is and where it really ends up. Published ... , their study found that nearly a quarter of ... developing countries with major potential health risks for ... colleagues note that the export from developed to developing ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):ETH student develops filter for clean water around the world 2Dead body feeding larvae useful in forensic investigations 2
(Date:7/23/2014)... July 23, 2014 regulated information -- UCB today ... development pipeline with positive topline results from the ... study was designed to evaluate the efficacy and ... mg/day, without titration) compared to placebo, as adjunctive ... seizures, not fully controlled despite treatment with one ...
(Date:7/23/2014)... -- China Cord Blood Corporation (NYSE: CO ) ("CCBC" ... cord blood collection, laboratory testing, hematopoietic stem cell processing, and stem ... company catering to the mother and child segment, today announced that ... PRC, Singapore , Hong Kong ... the Philippines and Malaysia ...
(Date:7/23/2014)... Adult stem cells that are ... but not magical. However, many current regenerative ... as if they were magical. , Many current ... constitute “stem cell tourism,” are evaluating heterologous tissue ... new regenerative medicine therapies. In reality, these are ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... D.C., June 22, 2014 Even within a phylum so ... is distinguished among other arthropods for its cruelty -- at ... Central America, the fly is a most predatory sort of ... cricket, deposits a smear of larvae, and leaves its wicked ... out. , None of this would be possible without ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 2Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 3Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 4Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 5Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 6Major advance in UCB pipeline: positive topline Phase 3 results for brivaracetam in epilepsy patients with partial-onset seizures 7China Cord Blood Corporation and Cordlife Group Limited Announce Collaboration to Aid Asia-based Patients with Cord Blood Stem Cell Therapy 2China Cord Blood Corporation and Cordlife Group Limited Announce Collaboration to Aid Asia-based Patients with Cord Blood Stem Cell Therapy 3China Cord Blood Corporation and Cordlife Group Limited Announce Collaboration to Aid Asia-based Patients with Cord Blood Stem Cell Therapy 4The Adult Stem Cell Technology Center, LLC Continues to Develop Technologies for Homologous Adult Stem Cell Therapies and Drug Development 2The Adult Stem Cell Technology Center, LLC Continues to Develop Technologies for Homologous Adult Stem Cell Therapies and Drug Development 3The Adult Stem Cell Technology Center, LLC Continues to Develop Technologies for Homologous Adult Stem Cell Therapies and Drug Development 4The Adult Stem Cell Technology Center, LLC Continues to Develop Technologies for Homologous Adult Stem Cell Therapies and Drug Development 5Fly-inspired sound detector 2Fly-inspired sound detector 3Fly-inspired sound detector 4
Cached News: