HOME >> BIOLOGY >> NEWS
Medical research scientists make ethical value judgments in research

NEW YORK (May 14, 2007) -- Medical research scientists in public health and other areas routinely make ethical value judgments, even if they're not aware of it, according to a new Weill Cornell Medical College research study. And not only do these judgments not lead to bias necessarily, but they can make for better research.

Published in the current issue of European Journal of Epidemiology, the paper finds that the framing of the research question, identification of the problem, as well as the design and methodology of the study are all subject to value judgments by investigators.

To illustrate this point, the study focuses on how value judgments are made in epidemiological research of racial health disparities.

"Epidemiologists must endorse particular public policy aims of the research in order to make methodological decisions throughout the research process. In the case of research into racial disparities, the researcher decides how to define race -- whether by genetic markers or by census data. Both definitions are valid on their own, but in deciding which one to use, the scientist makes value assumptions about which would best promote the social aims of the research, such as eliminating racial disparities," says Dr. Inmaculada de Melo-Martn, the study's co-author and associate professor in the Division of Medical Ethics in the Department of Public Health at Weill Cornell Medical College.

"Also, scientists make value judgments in deciding which areas of research to pursue. For example, if the recommendations likely to result from additional genetic research are already part of standard medical practice, or if the new drugs resulting from genetic research would likely be too expensive for minority groups, then genetic research may not be the most effective way of trying to decrease racial health disparities," notes Dr. de Melo-Martn.

"In fact, many medical research scientists make these value judgments without
'"/>

Contact: Andrew Klein
ank2017@med.cornell.edu
212-821-0560
New York- Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center/Weill Cornell Medical College
14-May-2007


Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Ossurs PROPRIO FOOT takes the Gold 2007 Medical Design Excellence Award
2. Innovative smallpox vaccine research study to be conducted at Case Medical Center
3. Vitamin extends life in yeast, Dartmouth Medical School researchers find
4. Ossurs Proprio Foot walks away with 2007 Medical Design Excellence Award
5. University of Minnesotas 6th annual Design of Medical Devices Conference to be held April 17-19
6. Columbia University Medical Center awarded $3 million to drive Alzheimers genetics research
7. Burnham Institute for Medical Research announces affiliation with UC Santa Barbara
8. Yale scientist honored with Keio University Medical Science Prize
9. American College of Medical Genetics -- 2007 Annual Clinical Genetics Meeting Announcement
10. Breast Cancer Month story tips from Georgetown University Medical Center
11. Columbia University Medical Center receives major new NIH Clinical Science investment funds

Post Your Comments:
(Date:7/24/2014)... gathered at NJIT this week for an all-day public ... Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to dredge toxic sediment from ... The EPA has called the plan, which proposes removing ... sections of the riverbed, one of the largest cleanups ... dredged and disposed off-site. , "We need to ensure ...
(Date:7/24/2014)... To reduce fire hazard in the United States, wildland ... woody shrubs and suppressed trees (ladder fuels). These ... periods of low fire danger in order to dispose ... hazardous air pollutants, managers often cover all or part ... referred to as agricultural plastic, in order to keep ...
(Date:7/24/2014)... by the New Jersey Recovery Fund and conducted by ... and Public Policy at Rutgers University has found that ... the likelihood of community-based rebuilding solutions. Of the more ... were "pessimistic" or "very pessimistic" that the parts of ... better than they were before the storm; another 24 ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):Experts Weigh the Pros and Cons of a $1.7 Billion EPA Cleanup Plan for the Passaic River at an NJIT 2Study gives new perspective on agricultural plastic, debris burning, and air quality 2Rutgers study explores attitudes, preferences toward post-Sandy rebuilding 2
(Date:7/25/2014)... WABC Radio show out of New York City, ... will be hosting California-based Vet-Stem, Inc.’s Founder and CEO, Robert ... pets. Dr. Harman first visited the show in November ... pets suffering from osteoarthritis and other degenerative diseases, as well ... , Young has invited Dr. Harman back to dial down ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... (PRWEB) July 25, 2014 The Conferee ... for Topics for Conferee Networking. These two-hour sessions provide ... to meet and resolve problems, discuss new techniques, or ... deadline to submit a topic for consideration is August ... pittcon.org . The Conferee Networking committee will review the ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... California (PRWEB) July 25, 2014 Lawrence ... named to Thomson Reuters list of " The World's ... are part of the 3,000 researchers who were identified ... to recognize those who published the highest-impact work (2002-2012 ... research papers on combustion modeling . , "This ...
(Date:7/25/2014)... , July 25, 2014  Galmed Pharmaceuticals Ltd. ... company focused on the development and commercialization of a ... and cholesterol gallstones, today announced financial results for the ... 2014 Financial Summary: , Reported cash and cash ... with $137,000 at December 31, 2013.  , Reported ...
Breaking Biology Technology:Robert J. Harman, DVM, Founder and CEO of Vet-Stem, Inc. to Join New York Radio Host Lorry Young in Upcoming Episode of A “Paws” For Your Pet 2Robert J. Harman, DVM, Founder and CEO of Vet-Stem, Inc. to Join New York Radio Host Lorry Young in Upcoming Episode of A “Paws” For Your Pet 3Pittcon 2015 Announces Call for Topics for Conferee Networking Sessions 2Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 2Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 3Scientists Burst onto Influential List for Combustion Research 4Galmed Pharmaceuticals Reports First Half 2014 Financial Results 2Galmed Pharmaceuticals Reports First Half 2014 Financial Results 3Galmed Pharmaceuticals Reports First Half 2014 Financial Results 4Galmed Pharmaceuticals Reports First Half 2014 Financial Results 5Galmed Pharmaceuticals Reports First Half 2014 Financial Results 6
Cached News: