HOME >> BIOLOGY >> NEWS
Moral judgment fails without feelings

Consider the following scenario: someone you know has AIDS and plans to infect others, some of whom will die. Your only options are to let it happen or to kill the person.

Do you pull the trigger?

Most people waver or say they could not, even if they agree that in theory they should. But according to a new study in the journal Nature, subjects with damage to a part of the frontal lobe make a less personal calculation.

The logical choice, they say, is to sacrifice one life to save many.

Conducted by researchers at the University of Southern California, Harvard University, Caltech and the University of Iowa, the study shows that emotion plays an important role in scenarios that pose a moral dilemma.

If certain emotions are blocked, we make decisions that right or wrong seem unnaturally cold.

The scenarios in the study are extreme, but the core dilemma is not: should one confront a co-worker, challenge a neighbor, or scold a loved one in the interest of the greater good?

A total of 30 subjects of both genders faced a set of scenarios pitting immediate harm to one person against future certain harm to many. Six had damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (VMPC), a small region behind the forehead, while 12 had brain damage elsewhere, and another 12 had no damage.

The subjects with VMPC damage stood out in their stated willingness to harm an individual a prospect that usually generates strong aversion.

Because of their brain damage, they have abnormal social emotions in real life. They lack empathy and compassion, said Ralph Adolphs, Bren Professor of Psychology and Neuroscience at Caltech.

In those circumstances most people without this specific brain damage will be torn. But these particular subjects seem to lack that conflict, said co-senior author Antonio Damasio, director of the Brain and Creativity Institute and holder of the David Dornsife Chair in Neuros
'"/>

Contact: Carl Marziali
marziali@usc.edu
213-219-6347
University of Southern California
21-Mar-2007


Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Medical research scientists make ethical value judgments in research
2. Snap judgments decide a faces character, psychologist finds
3. Study fails to verify gene variations as risk factors for certain cardiovascular problems
4. Getting ones protein in a bunch -- When quality control fails in cells
5. Early HIV treatment fails to restore memory T cells
6. Promising antiobesity drug fails to produce clinically meaningful weight loss
7. Reconstructed 1918 influenza virus induces immune response that fails to protect
8. Nilotinib appears to help chronic myelogenous leukemia patients when standard care fails
9. Subsidized killing of carnivores fails to protect US sheep industry
10. Researchers explain why badger culling fails to control cattle TB
11. Blocking cell suicide switch fails to stop prion damage in mouse brains

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:6/6/2019)... ... 05, 2019 , ... Pelican BioThermal , the global ... service center in Mexico City, Mexico. Mexico is the second largest pharmaceutical market ... $1.75 billion in pharmaceutical exports since 2015. The Mexico City network station will ...
(Date:6/4/2019)... ... June 04, 2019 , ... ... salient features of seizure risk signals, usually based on variations of amplitude, frequency ... the only acceptable diagnostic methodology due to the complexity and variability of the ...
(Date:5/31/2019)... ... May 30, 2019 , ... Researchers ... Mayo Clinic, have documented significant differences in the prevalence of hereditary genetic mutations, ... compared to non-Hispanic White women. Results will be presented at the 2019 American ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:5/15/2019)... ... May 16, 2019 , ... Emulsifiers are the magic bullet ... products rely on these ingredients to create stable quality food that can withstand ... shift triggers food formulators to seek out alternatives for starches, gums and chemical ...
(Date:5/7/2019)... ... May 06, 2019 , ... ... for the growing number of repositories being asked to store cellular products ... the team of contributors who are world leaders, who have shared their expertise ...
(Date:5/2/2019)... S.D. (PRWEB) , ... April 30, 2019 , ... The ... from industrial scale macro breweries to local craft breweries, and even home brewing clubs ... very complex chemical and biological processes, that when mastered can produce a superb product. ...
(Date:4/25/2019)... ... 2019 , ... Frank is an albino, deaf Great Dane. His owners rescued him when he ... health issues. Despite his hearing impairment, he was always an active and playful pup. Frank ... day, every day. As the two grew, playtime became rougher and Frank ended up injuring ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
Cached News: