HOME >> BIOLOGY >> NEWS
What is wrong with intelligent design?

In a thought-provoking paper from the March issue of The Quarterly Review of Biology , Elliott Sober (University of Wisconsin) clearly discusses the problems with two standard criticisms of intelligent design: that it is unfalsifiable and that the many imperfect adaptations found in nature refute the hypothesis of intelligent design.

Biologists from Charles Darwin to Stephen Jay Gould have advanced this second type of argument. Stephen Jay Gould's well-known example of a trait of this type is the panda's thumb. If a truly intelligent designer were responsible for the panda, Gould argues, it would have provided a more useful tool than the stubby proto-thumb that pandas use to laboriously strip bamboo in order to eat it.

ID proponents have a ready reply to this objection. We do not know whether an intelligent designer intended for pandas to be able to efficiently strip bamboo. The "no designer worth his salt" argument assumes the designer would want pandas to have better eating implements, but the objection has no justification for this assumption. In addition, Sober points out, this criticism of ID also concedes that creationism is testable.

A second common criticism of ID is that it is untestable. To develop this point, scientists often turn to the philosopher Karl Popper's idea of falsifiability. According to Popper, a scientific statement must allow the possibility of an observation that would disprove it. For example, the statement "all swans are white" is falsifiable, since observing even one swan that isn't white would disprove it. Sober points out that this criterion entails that many ID statements are falsifiable; for example, the statement that an intelligent designer created the vertebrate eye entails that vertebrates have eyes, which is an observation.

This leads Sober to jettison the concept of falsifiability and to provide a different account of testability. "If ID is to be tested," he says, "it must be teste
'"/>

Contact: Suzanne Wu
swu@press.uchicago.edu
773-834-0386
University of Chicago Press Journals
22-Feb-2007


Page: 1 2

Related biology news :

1. Right angles are all wrong for tree frog adhesion
2. Protein from the wrong side of the tracks aids cancer virus
3. Arthritis: What Wnt wrong?
4. Psychologist finds instance where two wrongs do make a right
5. Dover intelligent design decision to be topic of national forum
6. Cell biologists applaud intelligent design ruling
7. From intelligent cars to the prevention of heart attacks
8. New book explains how evolution really works, rebuts intelligent design

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:8/7/2020)... ... August 06, 2020 , ... Nine ... prestigious National STEM Scholar Program, a unique professional development program that provides advanced ... for middle school science teachers nationwide. , Created in partnership between the National ...
(Date:8/3/2020)... , ... August 03, 2020 , ... ... announced a new partnership with medical equipment manufacturer, Spectrum Solutions, to provide COVID-19 ... to strengthen their laboratory supply chain for more than 10 years. Early in ...
(Date:7/31/2020)... ... July 30, 2020 , ... ... product portfolio with a near term focus on Type 2 diabetes and associated ... experience across multiple therapeutic areas and classes. As Chief Commercial Officer, Justin will ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:7/22/2020)... ... 2020 , ... Join experts from Reed Tech , Gary Saner, Sr. ... one hour live webinar on Thursday, August 13, 2020 at 11am EDT ... medical devices. Specifically, for medical devices, the NMPA has departments dealing with medical device ...
(Date:7/10/2020)... ... July 08, 2020 , ... Bode Technology, ... of laboratory operations through its COVID-19 testing service, Bode-CARES . Bode-CARES combines ... Bode-CARES provides a turnkey solution that includes a comprehensive collection and ...
(Date:7/7/2020)... ... July 06, 2020 , ... Bio-IT World has announced ... Bristol-Myers Squibb, the University of Chicago, Massachusetts General Hospital, Mission: Cure, and the ... awards program, highlighting outstanding examples of how technology innovations and strategic initiatives can ...
(Date:6/28/2020)... , ... June 25, 2020 , ... ... racing to develop a vaccine or drug treatment. In an effort to better ... has publicly released the world’s largest imaging dataset portraying therapeutic compound effects from ...
Breaking Biology Technology:
Cached News: