PHILADELPHIA With medical liability insurance premiums skyrocketing, the role of a physician expert witness and how they can contribute to increasing malpractice costs is certainly controversial. Love them or hate them, expert witnesses are a necessary component of the United States' legal system. Untruthful testimony, however, can punish good doctors and push the medical community's overall medical liability insurance premiums up, which forces many physicians to modify their practice and pass costs on to their patients, according to a panel held today at the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) Plastic Surgery 2004 conference in Philadelphia.
"No doubt there are people who have had surgery, and malpractice has been committed," said Paul Weiss, MD, former chair of the ASPS Task Force on Expert Witness Testimony and panel participant. "ASPS believes those patients deserve to be protected and have their day in court. However, we also believe that physicians who offer untruthful and misleading testimony that does not match the industry's standard of care to support a malpractice case should be culled out of the system for everyone's benefit."
In response to this growing dilemma, ASPS created a document that calls for an expert witness to affirm, among other things, that the witness has relevant expertise to the procedure in question and will provide truthful and impartial testimony based on the standard of care in the community. ASPS encourages members to sign this document before testifying and present it to the attorney representing the party for whom they intend to testify. Witnesses who have signed the affirmation can use it to bolster their qualifications on direct examination. Conversely, witnesses who choose not to sign it can be cross-examined about their failure to do so.
While some medical expert witnesses are purposefully deceitful, many simply do not have the in-depth and wide knowledge base to appropriately comment onPage: 1 2 Related medicine news :1
Contact: Brian Hugins
American Society of Plastic Surgeons
. New colorectal cancer screening recommendations for African Americans2
. Community care tops medical care at preventing heart disease in black Americans3
. Researchers say breast cancer in Africa may provide clues to the disease in African-Americans4
. African-Americans receive less aggressive heart attack treatment5
. Americans support most uses of reproductive genetic testing, report on US attitudes reveals6
. African-Americans may need more medication to control asthma7
. Good medicine, good economics: African-Americans need equal treatment for pain, SLU study finds8
. Beliefs may hinder HIV prevention among African-Americans9
. African Americans half as likely to receive surgery for esophageal cancer10
. Study suggests obesity has lesser financial impact on African-Americans11
. Few Americans are aware they have chronic kidney disease