HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Are UK consent rules too restrictive?

Regulations on the use of human tissue in the United Kingdom are now more restrictive than any other European country. Is the UK leading the way or overreacting to recent publicity about inadequate consent procedures?

The new regulations require explicit consent from every patient. Explicit consent is appropriate for the use of emotionally important samples such as post-mortem tissue, but the new regulations also apply to all samples from living patients, including resected tumours, tiny biopsies, even blood and urine.

Although this takes due account of the autonomy of the few who object, it is now inhibiting work done for the good of everyone and has other ethically undesirable consequences, says Professor Peter Furness, in this week's BMJ.

Recording the wishes of all patients whenever samples are taken would resolve this problem but this has major resource implications, he writes. So is implied consent - asking the few who object to make their wishes known a reasonable possibility for the use of tissue from living patients for research?

Implied consent was recommended by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics in 1995, but has since been rejected by the Medical Research Council, despite evidence that patients thought it was appropriate. The Department of Health for England has so far taken a similar line to the MRC.

"If we are serious about empowering patients to control the use of their tissue samples, resources must be allocated irrespective of whether implied or explicit consent is regarded as appropriate," says the author. "Without such resources our laboratories are forced into paralysis or continuing paternalism. At present we have both."


'"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-207-383-6529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
2-Oct-2003


Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Obtaining patient consent for clinical audit is unworkable without extra resources
2. Improving informed consent for children in cancer treatment studies
3. Discussion plus pamphlet better than just discussion for informed consent
4. Informed consent does not seem to influence decision-making process for cataract surgery
5. Early use of universal forms boosts informed consent among ICU patients
6. New approach required for obtaining informed consent in less-developed countries
7. People are unlikely to withdraw consent for genetic research
8. New consent rules may threaten our health
9. Audiovisual recording of oral consent for illiterate populations (p 1406)
10. Researchers recommend community advisory boards to prevent lapses in informed consent
11. New study provides mixed report card on informed consent to cancer clinical trials

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Are consent rules too restrictive

(Date:10/31/2014)... Fundraising support for fighting cancer prompts many creative events—the results ... Monday, November 10 in the paramedic garage at Soldiers ... Health (SH) employees and community members will gather together to ... new Cancer Center at SSMH. Three beauticians will be on ... and support to which many who have been touched by ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... Cambridge, Mass. Friday. October 31, 2014 — A ... California, Berkeley, and the University of California, Santa ... Institute (NCI) Cancer Genomics Cloud Pilot contracts with ... enable large-scale analysis of The Cancer Genome Atlas ... and the required computing resources in one cloud ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... 2014 At the start of 2014, ... escaping carbon monoxide poisoning in their homes. Now, as ... one family-owned, Missouri-based heating and cooling company is taking ... families start the home heating season with the assurance ... , Beginning Nov. 1, 2014, E and Q Heating ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... FRIDAY, Oct. 31, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Sleep apnea may ... as where you parked your car or left your house ... with severe sleep apnea showed that this ability -- called ... eye movement (REM) sleep, even when other stages of sleep ... during which dreams typically occur. "We,ve shown for the ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... device to give cancer researchers an unprecedented microscopic look ... through the body, causing more than 90 percent of ... cells travel, the device could uncover new ways to ... university,s Whiting School of Engineering and its Institute for ... system recently in the journal Cancer Research . ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Susquehanna Health Soldiers + Sailors Memorial Hospital Razing Heads to Fight Cancer 2Health News:Broad Institute, Univ. of California team awarded NCI Cancer Genomics Cloud Pilot contract 2Health News:Broad Institute, Univ. of California team awarded NCI Cancer Genomics Cloud Pilot contract 3Health News:Many Homeowners Missing Key Safety Risks with Home Heating;Missouri-based Company E and Q Announces New Safety Check 2Health News:Many Homeowners Missing Key Safety Risks with Home Heating;Missouri-based Company E and Q Announces New Safety Check 3Health News:Sleep Apnea May Steal Some of Your Memory: Study 2Health News:Viewing cancer on the move: New device yields close-up look at metastasis 2Health News:Viewing cancer on the move: New device yields close-up look at metastasis 3
(Date:10/31/2014)... and BARCELONA , October 31, ... (Multigate) was found to infringe two Australian patents of B. ... sale in Australia safety IV catheters ... in Federal Court of Australia proceeding ... http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/FCA/2014/1110.html . In the detailed judgment, Multigate ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... 2014 Migranade, Inc. announced today the new ... the 36 million U.S. migraine sufferers November, 2014. The ... the actual cause of migraines and not just the ... the source Migranade is assured to be a game ... is available at http://www.migranade.com and will soon ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... 30, 2014 Electronic prescribing or ... of prescription related information between prescriber, dispenser ... a physician and nurse practitioner to transmit ... error occurs during pharmacy operations. E-Prescribing system ... provides complete medical lists, conducts all security ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:B. Braun Wins Patent Disputes Against Poly Medicure Ltd's Australian Distributor Multigate Medical Devices Pty. Ltd. and Spanish Distributor Dextromédica S. L. 2Game Changing Migraine Medication To Be Available November 2014 2E-Prescribing Market - Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, Trends and Forecast, 2013 - 2019 2
Cached News: