HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Are UK consent rules too restrictive?

Regulations on the use of human tissue in the United Kingdom are now more restrictive than any other European country. Is the UK leading the way or overreacting to recent publicity about inadequate consent procedures?

The new regulations require explicit consent from every patient. Explicit consent is appropriate for the use of emotionally important samples such as post-mortem tissue, but the new regulations also apply to all samples from living patients, including resected tumours, tiny biopsies, even blood and urine.

Although this takes due account of the autonomy of the few who object, it is now inhibiting work done for the good of everyone and has other ethically undesirable consequences, says Professor Peter Furness, in this week's BMJ.

Recording the wishes of all patients whenever samples are taken would resolve this problem but this has major resource implications, he writes. So is implied consent - asking the few who object to make their wishes known a reasonable possibility for the use of tissue from living patients for research?

Implied consent was recommended by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics in 1995, but has since been rejected by the Medical Research Council, despite evidence that patients thought it was appropriate. The Department of Health for England has so far taken a similar line to the MRC.

"If we are serious about empowering patients to control the use of their tissue samples, resources must be allocated irrespective of whether implied or explicit consent is regarded as appropriate," says the author. "Without such resources our laboratories are forced into paralysis or continuing paternalism. At present we have both."


'"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-207-383-6529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
2-Oct-2003


Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Obtaining patient consent for clinical audit is unworkable without extra resources
2. Improving informed consent for children in cancer treatment studies
3. Discussion plus pamphlet better than just discussion for informed consent
4. Informed consent does not seem to influence decision-making process for cataract surgery
5. Early use of universal forms boosts informed consent among ICU patients
6. New approach required for obtaining informed consent in less-developed countries
7. People are unlikely to withdraw consent for genetic research
8. New consent rules may threaten our health
9. Audiovisual recording of oral consent for illiterate populations (p 1406)
10. Researchers recommend community advisory boards to prevent lapses in informed consent
11. New study provides mixed report card on informed consent to cancer clinical trials

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Are consent rules too restrictive

(Date:11/21/2014)... The typical Thanksgiving dinner table is ... of gravy and a myriad of mouthwatering desserts. Who ... of year to begin losing weight? Listen closely. With ... secret to losing unhealthy, embarrassing and uncomfortable fat while ... The insight to Diet Doc’s calorie loading holiday ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... Florida (PRWEB) November 21, 2014 TruDenta, ... chronic headaches and other jaw-related symptoms, has ... seeking relief from chronic head pain, neck pain, TMJ ... , “This year we have seen a 52% increase ... Our network of over 300 doctors and their teams ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... Even with years of experience under his belt, Kirk ... growth, participating in two recent events for his State Farm ... networking event with the leaders of State Farm and thousands ... and greatest in insurance news and products for his clients. ... (Stacy, Anthony, Reina and Jacob) as exhibitors at the recent ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... 2014 First Choice Emergency Room ... The new facility is located at 225 E. Parkwood ... “We are pleased to join the Friendswood community and ... care here,” said Dr. Siddiqi, Facility Medical Director of ... celebrate the opening, First Choice Emergency Room made a ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... HealthDay Reporter THURSDAY, Nov. 20, 2014 ... of a still-beating heart has the potential to improve the ... new study. Heart patients who received the gel implant ... hundreds of feet farther during a six-minute walk test, said ... cardiovascular division at Washington University School of Medicine and a ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Diet Doc Releases New Calorie Loading Diet Plans - the Perfect Way to Jump Start the Metabolism and Begin Weight Loss During Thanksgiving 2Health News:Diet Doc Releases New Calorie Loading Diet Plans - the Perfect Way to Jump Start the Metabolism and Begin Weight Loss During Thanksgiving 3Health News:Diet Doc Releases New Calorie Loading Diet Plans - the Perfect Way to Jump Start the Metabolism and Begin Weight Loss During Thanksgiving 4Health News:National Rise In Patients Seeking Headache Relief 2Health News:Kirk Martin Insurance Agency Goes Local and National with State Farm 2Health News:First Choice Emergency Room Opens New Facility in Friendswood, Texas 2Health News:Gel Implant Might Help Fight Heart Failure 2Health News:Gel Implant Might Help Fight Heart Failure 3
(Date:11/21/2014)... NEW YORK , Nov. 20, 2014  Market research ... as the "Year of The Buy, in the medical ... market for medical devices will produce just 3% growth ... competitive actions, including acquisitions of product lines and entrance ... an annual survey of medical devices, The Global ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... Nov. 20, 2014  The acceptance of two ... AAGL Global Congress demonstrates continued interest in the ... provide bowel control. One of the abstracts, presented by ... Division Chief of Urogynecology and Reconstructive Pelvic Surgery ... Award for Best Written Abstract on Urogynecology/Pelvic Floor ...
(Date:11/21/2014)... Nov. 20, 2014 Oxis International, Inc. (OXIS) (OXI.PA) ... election of Anthony J. Cataldo as Chief Executive ... Effective November 19, 2014, Ken Eaton resigned his ... of Directors of Oxis International, Inc. to pursue new opportunities. ... named Chief Executive Officer of Oxis International, Inc. Mr. Cataldo ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Kalorama: 2014 The "Year of The Buy" in Medical Device Industry 2LIFE Study Prominently Featured at Minimally Invasive Gynecology Conference 2LIFE Study Prominently Featured at Minimally Invasive Gynecology Conference 3OXIS International, Inc. announces Changes in Management Team 2OXIS International, Inc. announces Changes in Management Team 3
Cached News: