HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Avoiding wishful thinking over new drugs more trials should be double-blinded say cancer experts

Italian researchers have urged that doctors should, wherever possible, be blinded to which drug a patient is receiving in a trial when the endpoint involves subjective judgements by the investigators.

They believe it would lessen the risk of wishful thinking an unconscious tendency by doctors to expect new drugs to perform better than the older ones they are being tested against.

This perception of a drugs effectiveness was named wish bias', when it was first reported more than a decade ago. In a report published in the current issue of Annals of Oncology* the research team says it may help to explain why the response rate of tumours to a new drug decreased over time.

Dr Roldano Fossati and colleagues from the Mario Negri Institute in Milan combed through the results of 29 randomised trials that took place between 1975 and 1999. They analysed the response rate of 2,234 women with advanced breast cancer who had been in the arms of the trials using the anti-cancer drug, doxorubicin (Adriamycin). They extracted the global (i.e. complete plus partial) response rate from all the trials.

"We found that every five years there was a 11% relative decrease in the odds of a global response and most of this decrease was in the partial response rate, where evaluation involves more subjective judgement than is involved in determining complete response," said Dr Fossati.

Of the 29 studies they investigated, only one had used a double blind** approach, and in two studies patients records were just externally audited.

"In these situations a bias due to financial and academic conflicts of interest or more subtle forms of wish bias could easily arise and account for an impression that when a drug is new it does better," said Dr Fossati.

The team carried out the assessment of the 29 studies to test their hypothesis that doctors unconscious favourable attitudes to new treatments may result in a tendency to overestimate their
'"/>

Contact: Margaret Willson
m.willson@mwcommunications.org.uk
44-1536-772181
European Society for Medical Oncology
12-Mar-2002


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Chronic back pain shrinks thinking parts of the brain, study finds
2. Integration of agriculture, medicine requires new ways of thinking
3. Fit seniors better able to react when quick thinking needed, study says
4. Brain imaging technology can reveal what a person is thinking about
5. Research challenges conventional thinking on ways to treat prostate cancer
6. UW research shows risk factors for relapse among health care professionals who abuse drugs
7. New studies show mixed results on epilepsy drugs and birth defects
8. Newly discovered pathway might help in design of cancer drugs
9. Study examines consequences of Thailands war on drugs
10. Computational tool predicts how drugs work in cells, advancing efforts to design better medicines
11. Three anti-platelet drugs used in combination are safe

Post Your Comments:
(Date:3/5/2015)... At the 7th Annual Mississippi Addiction Conference ... met today in Jackson, Mississippi to listen to keynote ... numerous respected speakers will be William S. Jacobs, ... pain medications have had in today’s opiate overdose and ... is hard to believe that much of the current ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... University of Western States (UWS), ... has launched a new center of excellence to ... Northwest Center for Lifestyle and Functional Medicine aim ... and conduct research in the areas of lifestyle ... The center will target efforts on the UWS ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... NY (PRWEB) March 05, 2015 Dr. ... Surgeon ( http://www.orthopedicsurgeonnyc.com ) has been named by ... New York Metro area. Dr. Glashow has been selected ... authoritative guide to the top specialty care doctors in ... The prestigious Castle Connolly program, which carefully screens and ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... 05, 2015 Today, Earth Source ... on 100% pollution-free electricity through a partnership with ... As an Arcadia Power Clean Energy Partner, ESO ... Power Partnership requirements, joining national brands such as ... clean energy. Earth Source Organics joins a growing ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... Think it’s tough to get kids to ... them to brush their teeth. That’s a finding from a ... Delta Dental(1) in conjunction with National Parenting Month in March. ... kids to brush their teeth is one of the most ... higher than getting children to eat vegetables regularly (42 percent) ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:National Addiction Treatment Expert William S. “Bill” Jacobs, Md Speaks At Prestigious 7th Annual Mississippi Addiction Conference 2Health News:National Addiction Treatment Expert William S. “Bill” Jacobs, Md Speaks At Prestigious 7th Annual Mississippi Addiction Conference 3Health News:University of Western States Launches Northwest Center for Lifestyle and Functional Medicine 2Health News:Dr. Jonathan Glashow, NYC Orthopedic Surgeon, Named Top Doctor: New York Metro Area 2Health News:Earth Source Organics to Run on Clean Energy from Arcadia Power 2Health News:Delta Dental Survey Says Parents Have Harder Time Getting Kids to Brush than to Eat Vegetables 2Health News:Delta Dental Survey Says Parents Have Harder Time Getting Kids to Brush than to Eat Vegetables 3
(Date:3/5/2015)... , March 5, 2015  ContraVir Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ: ... the development and commercialization of targeted antiviral therapies, announced ... Annual ROTH Conference, to be held March 8-11, ... James Sapirstein , Chief Executive Officer, ... his live presentation and will be available to participate ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... Calif. , March 5, 2015  Asterias Biotherapeutics, ... the emerging field of regenerative medicine, announced today that ... the nation,s top rehabilitation hospitals for spinal cord injury ... 1/2a clinical trial of AST-OPC1 (oligodendrocyte progenitor cells) in ... spinal cord injury (SCI). The Phase ...
(Date:3/5/2015)... YORK and VANCOUVER, British Columbia ... (CSE: BUX FSE: 20B OTCQB: BMKDF) -- The ultimate ... an assay that is capable of detecting tumors before ... forty years, the development of such an assay has ... in academia and industry. Although many breakthrough diagnostics have ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:ContraVir to Present at 27th Annual ROTH Conference 2Asterias Biotherapeutics Initiates Patient Enrollment for Phase 1/2a Clinical Trial of AST-OPC1 in Newly Injured People with Complete Cervical Spinal Cord Injury 2Asterias Biotherapeutics Initiates Patient Enrollment for Phase 1/2a Clinical Trial of AST-OPC1 in Newly Injured People with Complete Cervical Spinal Cord Injury 3Asterias Biotherapeutics Initiates Patient Enrollment for Phase 1/2a Clinical Trial of AST-OPC1 in Newly Injured People with Complete Cervical Spinal Cord Injury 4New Cancer Diagnostic Primed to Change the Industry 2New Cancer Diagnostic Primed to Change the Industry 3New Cancer Diagnostic Primed to Change the Industry 4
Cached News: