HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Avoiding wishful thinking over new drugs more trials should be double-blinded say cancer experts

Italian researchers have urged that doctors should, wherever possible, be blinded to which drug a patient is receiving in a trial when the endpoint involves subjective judgements by the investigators.

They believe it would lessen the risk of wishful thinking an unconscious tendency by doctors to expect new drugs to perform better than the older ones they are being tested against.

This perception of a drugs effectiveness was named wish bias', when it was first reported more than a decade ago. In a report published in the current issue of Annals of Oncology* the research team says it may help to explain why the response rate of tumours to a new drug decreased over time.

Dr Roldano Fossati and colleagues from the Mario Negri Institute in Milan combed through the results of 29 randomised trials that took place between 1975 and 1999. They analysed the response rate of 2,234 women with advanced breast cancer who had been in the arms of the trials using the anti-cancer drug, doxorubicin (Adriamycin). They extracted the global (i.e. complete plus partial) response rate from all the trials.

"We found that every five years there was a 11% relative decrease in the odds of a global response and most of this decrease was in the partial response rate, where evaluation involves more subjective judgement than is involved in determining complete response," said Dr Fossati.

Of the 29 studies they investigated, only one had used a double blind** approach, and in two studies patients records were just externally audited.

"In these situations a bias due to financial and academic conflicts of interest or more subtle forms of wish bias could easily arise and account for an impression that when a drug is new it does better," said Dr Fossati.

The team carried out the assessment of the 29 studies to test their hypothesis that doctors unconscious favourable attitudes to new treatments may result in a tendency to overestimate their
'"/>

Contact: Margaret Willson
m.willson@mwcommunications.org.uk
44-1536-772181
European Society for Medical Oncology
12-Mar-2002


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Chronic back pain shrinks thinking parts of the brain, study finds
2. Integration of agriculture, medicine requires new ways of thinking
3. Fit seniors better able to react when quick thinking needed, study says
4. Brain imaging technology can reveal what a person is thinking about
5. Research challenges conventional thinking on ways to treat prostate cancer
6. UW research shows risk factors for relapse among health care professionals who abuse drugs
7. New studies show mixed results on epilepsy drugs and birth defects
8. Newly discovered pathway might help in design of cancer drugs
9. Study examines consequences of Thailands war on drugs
10. Computational tool predicts how drugs work in cells, advancing efforts to design better medicines
11. Three anti-platelet drugs used in combination are safe

Post Your Comments:
(Date:3/31/2015)... Karen A. Daley, Ph.D. will address graduates ... Commencement ceremony on May 9, 2015 and will ... of her eminent career as a nurse, public health ... and senior staff nurse at Brigham and Women’s Hospital ... roles, including President of the American Nurses Association in ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... March 31, 2015 Medical DNA Labs, ... met all criteria for Laboratory Accreditation by COLA, a ... to laboratories that apply rigid standards of quality in ... proficiency testing, and pass a rigorous on-site laboratory survey. ... as a result of a long-term commitment to provide ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... On March 26, 2015, Vogue Magazine UK, ... Slope?” provides a look into the trend of young women ... laser treatments . The article suggests that celebrity endorsements (Beyoncé ... as Kim Kardashian and Kylie Jenner are the drivers behind ... as significant influences on the self-esteem of teenagers. (see: goo.gl/NmaB4q) ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... Plains, NJ (PRWEB) March 31, 2015 Dr. ... Spear Education Institute for Advanced Dental Education. Here, he ... hands-on workshop designed to create a greater predictability in cases ... on the etiologies of tooth wear, and the correlation to ... is also a Mentor at Spear Education. After the ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... Dr. Uzma Parvez is having a busy start to ... Grounds Presentations at St. Michael’s Medical Center for attending staff ... The event was attended by a large gathering of students, ... from the Grand Rounds. It was said that it ... while. , Ahead, Dr. Parvez has been invited to ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Rivier University to recognize nurse leader, educator and safety advocate at 80th Commencement on May 9th 2Health News:Rivier University to recognize nurse leader, educator and safety advocate at 80th Commencement on May 9th 3Health News:Local Medical DNA Labs, LLC. Recognized for Quality Laboratory Services 2Health News:Cosmetic Surgery: Does Social Media Pressure Young Girls to Get Botox and Fillers? 2Health News:The dentists at Upper Montclair Dental Associates are happy to announce exciting new happenings at their practice. 2Health News:NJ Top Docs Presents, Dr. Uzma Parvez of Total Pain Care 2
(Date:3/31/2015)... -- Ariana Smith, a 17-year-old Taylor teen, became the first patient ... a part of the Detroit Medical Center (DMC), and the ... a revolutionary 3D printed heart model to aid heart specialists ... In November, 2014, Ariana,s mom Jacqueline Foster ... a test that checks for problems with the electrical activity ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... ALPHARETTA, Ga. , March 31, 2015   ... Health Care, today announced it was awarded a new ... line of face masks. Effective March 1, 2015, Halyard,s ... masks with SO SOFT* lining, will be available to ... as well as 15,000 ambulatory surgery centers, physician practices ...
(Date:3/31/2015)... VICTORIA, BC , March 31, 2015 /CNW/ - T-Bird ... company focused on developing premium quality medical marijuana products ... the Marihuana for Medical Purposes Regulations ( Canada ... has received notice from The Corporation of the District ... rezoning approval of the Company,s premises which now allows ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Taylor Teen Becomes First Patient in Michigan to Benefit From 3D Printed Heart Model to Treat Life-Threatening Aneurysm 2Taylor Teen Becomes First Patient in Michigan to Benefit From 3D Printed Heart Model to Treat Life-Threatening Aneurysm 3Taylor Teen Becomes First Patient in Michigan to Benefit From 3D Printed Heart Model to Treat Life-Threatening Aneurysm 4Taylor Teen Becomes First Patient in Michigan to Benefit From 3D Printed Heart Model to Treat Life-Threatening Aneurysm 5Halyard Health Signs First GPO Contracts As Independent Company 2Halyard Health Signs First GPO Contracts As Independent Company 3T-Bird Pharma Inc. Announces Final Municipal Rezoning Approval 2T-Bird Pharma Inc. Announces Final Municipal Rezoning Approval 3
Cached News: