Concerns over national policy on infertility treatment

Decisions about providing fertility treatment on the NHS should be made locally according to need and priority, rather than through national policy, argues a leading medical ethicist in this week's BMJ.

His comments follow guidelines by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) that all couples meeting certain criteria should have up to three cycles of in vitro fertilisation free on the NHS.

The debate about publicly funding assisted conception is in essence a debate about values and priorities rather than a debate about what works, writes Richard Ashcroft of Imperial College London. Under a publicly funded NHS it is a political decision, not a clinical one, about how far we as a society want to provide fertility services and to whom.

Even with these guidelines it is unclear whether the government will ensure that appropriate resources are made available centrally. It is more likely that the guidelines will simply have to fit into existing locally made spending plans, he adds.

The guidelines from NICE temper local arbitrariness and unfairness, but they also tie the hands of the local decision makers whose job it is to set priorities.

We should be wary of making reproduction a major theme in our national politics, he warns. As long as people have reliable information and decision makers are accountable for the reasonableness of their decisions, why should there be national policy?


Contact: Emma Dickinson
BMJ-British Medical Journal

Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Concerns over the future of childrens health care in British general practice
2. Concerns about fertility affect treatment decisions in one-third of young breast cancer patients
3. Concerns over the value of animal experiments
4. UIC professor receives international humanitarian award
5. International breast cancer prevention study launches in the United States and Canada
6. National Academies advisory: May 2 Symposium on International Science Policy
7. NHS stop-smoking services are insufficient to deliver national smoking targets
8. Protecting human subjects focus of national FDA conference at UH
9. Awards & fellowships at the International & American Association for Dental Research General Session
10. Lectures, keynoters, symposia highlight International Dental Research meeting
11. Advances in Uterine Leiomyoma Research: 2nd NIH International Congress

Post Your Comments:

(Date:1/7/2020)... CITY and LAS VEGAS (PRWEB) , ... January 06, 2020 , ... ... announce its formation and unveil its first product: The LumaCare Duo ™. , ... booth (#44868) in the Sands Convention Center in Las Vegas, Nevada during CES 2020, ...
(Date:1/7/2020)... ... January 06, 2020 , ... A December 6 article on ... and fewer complications including high blood pressure and premature birth before or during second ... and their second pregnancies were less likely to suffer adverse pregnancy outcomes the second ...
(Date:1/7/2020)... ... January 07, 2020 , ... R3 Stem Cell is ... as the R3 Annual Membership, is available 24/7 and includes all the stem cell ... rate regenerative medicine training courses in person. For the online regenerative training courses, R3 ...
(Date:1/5/2020)... PLAINS, N.J. (PRWEB) , ... January 04, 2020 , ... ... His practice, Shore Children’s Dental Care, specializes in treatment for infants, children, teens and ... is announcing a new center for infant nursing and oral health. , Dr. Sherman ...
(Date:1/3/2020)... ... January 02, 2020 , ... ... lifestyle solutions, has announced the final round of U.S. finalists for its annual ... are Andrew Bischoff of Minnetonka, Minnesota; Ashley Pederson of St. Paul, Minnesota; Kim ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/7/2020)... ... January 06, 2020 , ... MemoryCare.com , a comprehensive ... Best Memory Care Facilities in Fargo, North Dakota. The guide identifies 2 memory ... , According to the Alzheimer’s Association , 5.6 million people age 65 ...
(Date:1/3/2020)... ... 2020 , ... ScreenPoint Medical’s Scientists who developed the Transpara ... and faster, say a new international study by Google Health and Imperial College, ... countries, including Hungary, Turkey, the USA and France. , The new study, published ...
(Date:1/3/2020)... , ... January 03, 2020 , ... American actor, Laurence ... and the “John Wick” series. While most know him for the movies he takes ... Scenes” with Laurence Fishburne. The show explores a vast range of topics to educate ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: