The Latest Biology News And Medical NewsBiology News 2Health News 2Biology News 3Health News 3
HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Criminalising medical mistakes is questionable

Using the criminal justice system to punish doctors who make mistakes is questionable, according to a barrister in this week's BMJ.

Citing the case of Feda Mulhem, who was sentenced to eight months in prison after supervising the mistaken injection of a drug into the spine of a teenager with cancer, Jon Holbrook argues that he was not seeking to harm his patient. In fact he was intending to further his recovery.

His "crime" was that he made a mistake; he confused a drug that is injected intravenously with a drug that is injected into the spine. Even the most diligent, conscientious, and competent practitioner will make mistakes, he says.

The recent increase in prosecutions for medical manslaughter reflects society's changed attitude towards the notion of gross negligence, he writes. Our modern day intolerance of accidents as innocent events has tended to turn medical mistakes resulting in death into tragedies calling for criminal investigation. "Dr Mulhem was not the first doctor to be convicted of killing by accident and sadly he is unlikely to be the last."


'"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-207-383-6529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
13-Nov-2003


Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Advertising by academic medical centers may risk eroding public trust, says study
2. NIH state-of-the-science panel calls for demedicalization of menopause
3. Community care tops medical care at preventing heart disease in black Americans
4. Breakthrough in medical research: New chemotherapy gives hope to brain tumour patients
5. Jefferson Lab medical imager spots breast cancer
6. Society of Hospital Medicine to launch new medical journal
7. LA BioMed medical/research briefs March 2005
8. Promising new strategy for Swedish medical research
9. Flu vaccination benefits people of any age with high-risk medical conditions
10. UCLA study: Nearly a third of drug ads in medical journals contain no references for medical claims
11. Electronic medical records reduce hours, cut cost

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Criminalising medical mistakes questionable

(Date:11/24/2009)...Newswire/--GovernorEdwardG.Rendelltodayannouncedth...cinatedduringtheweekendatpublichealthclinicsheldby..., "Withthefederalgovernmentunabletoprovideaccura...fH1N1vaccine,distributionhasbeenchallenging,"saidG...cinedistributionprocessinPennsylvania.Holdingpubli...
(Date:11/24/2009)...ire/--Nextmonth,UnitedHealthcarewilloffertwofreeMe...icanseniorsunderstandthebasicsofMedicare.Following...74;Goldclass,aLatin-infusedfitnessprogramthatblend... ,, UnitedHealthcarewilloffertheseseminarsinSpa...rningabouttheirhealthcareoptions. Thereareapproxi...
(Date:11/24/2009)...irstCall/--HealthSouthCorporation(NYSE: HLS )today...lLynch2009CreditConferenceinNewYorkonDec.2-3,2009....dFaywillbespeakingonThursday,Dec.3,2009,at3:40p.m....bleat http://investor.healthsouth.com byclickingon...althSouthisthenation,slargestproviderofinpatientre...
(Date:11/24/2009)...ospects, but cancer risk remains , , TUE...rs yet more proof that smoking is a major risk fac...Researchers followed 12,152 American and European ...okers for three years. During that time, current s...r, 2.26 times more likely to die of heart disease ...
(Date:11/24/2009)...udy conducted by Children,s Hospital & Research Ce...therapeutic agents found naturally in soy that can...d most deadly form of cancer. Sphingadienes (SDs) ...arch shows may be the key to fighting colon cancer...r scientist and director of the Cancer Center at C...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Governor Rendell Announces 100,000 At-Risk Pennsylvanians Vaccinated at H1N1 Public Health Clinics; Addresses Future Vaccine Distribution Plans 2Health News:UnitedHealthcare To Offer Seniors Hispanic-Centered Medicare Education Seminars Combined With a Latin-Themed Fitness Program 2Health News:Smokers Double Their Risk for Heart Disease 2Health News:Children's Hospital Oakland scientists discover soy component may be key to fighting colon cancer 2
(Date:11/24/2009).../-- InfiniteMind ,aSaltLakeCitybasedsoftwarecompan...ameyeQ,thesoftwareprogramistobeusedinconjunctionwi...introducedattheCOVDconferencethisOctoberinColorado...ievesthe eyeQ programaddssignificantvaluetohisprac...hispatientstoembedpracticesfromtheofficesettingtot...
(Date:11/24/2009)...Asia/--HuifengBio-Pharmaceutical,Technology,Inc.(O...,ofplantextractsandpharmaceuticalrawmaterialsforus...nXi,an,China,todayreportedthatinits,thirdquarter,t...venuesforthequarterendedSept.30,2009were$4,465,770...amequarterin2008.Netincome,amountedto1,002,005,or$...
(Date:11/24/2009)...stCall/--NeurocrineBiosciences,Inc.(Nasdaq: NBIX )...cutiveOfficerofNeurocrineBiosciences,willbepresent...inNewYork. ,, ThelivepresentationtakesplaceTues...m.PacificTime(PT).Thepresentationwillbesimultaneou...http://www.neurocrine.com . ,, Ifyouareunableto...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Infinite Mind Announces the Launch of a New Online Vision Therapy Program eyeQ 2Huifeng Bio-Pharmaceutical Technology Reports 26% Quarterly Revenue Increase 2Huifeng Bio-Pharmaceutical Technology Reports 26% Quarterly Revenue Increase 3This is a Test From PR Newswire Immediate Direct File 61877 1Alzheimer 26apos 3Bs Foundation of America Applauds Inclusion of Cognitive Impairment Detection in Healthcare Reform 61873 1Alzheimer 26apos 3Bs Foundation of America Applauds Inclusion of Cognitive Impairment Detection in Healthcare Reform 61873 2Alzheimer 26apos 3Bs Foundation of America Applauds Inclusion of Cognitive Impairment Detection in Healthcare Reform 61873 3Actuaries to Senate 3A Strengthen Individual Mandate 61868 1Actuaries to Senate 3A Strengthen Individual Mandate 61868 2
Other News:
...ompanies spend upward of $25 billion per year on p...o doctors, but new research shows such marketing d...prescribing behavior.... ...Direct-to-physician a... $5.3 billion spent on a practice called "detailin...
...ernment ponders the ethical implications of therap...e future. The Golden State has caught the attentio...akes its first steps toward becoming, thanks to Pr...l research, with government support to the tune of...
...degrading enzyme (IDE) is a protein known to play ...destructive plaques and tangles in the brains of A...own about the cellular and molecular regulation of... and human tissue, the research team 1) identified...
...e overweight or obese in young adulthood and middl...older age, compared to their nonoverweight peers, ...MA.......According to background information, obes...d pressure, diabetes, and certain cancers, and has...
health news:Pharmaceutical marketing tactics hold little sway with prescribing physicians 2health news:Pharmaceutical marketing tactics hold little sway with prescribing physicians 3health news:Stem cell research: The new medicine of the future 2health news:Stem cell research: The new medicine of the future 3health news:Health care charges higher for older adults who were overweight or obese when younger 2
...S recommendations for lowering cholesterol levels ...th no overall reduction in deaths, warn experts in...sterol Education Program has said that people at h...ggressively. ......By aggressively, it means that ...
...doses of some traditional non-steroidal anti-infla... cardiovascular risks as the new generation of ant...ke Vioxx ), finds a study in this week's BMJ. .......mbined analysis (known as a "meta-analysis") of al...
...ant women with female genital mutilation (FGM) hav...n after birth than those without, according to a p...rchers also found that women with FGM had more bir...edures that involve partial or total removal of th...
...S - June 1, 2006 - Adults need to be better educat... or programming, but the physical danger of fallin...cal Center study. ...UT Southwestern pediatricians...ases involving children injured by television sets...
health news:Female genital mutilation harmful for mothers and babies 2health news:Public needs to heighten awareness of dangers of elevated TVs that are larger, heavier 2health news:Public needs to heighten awareness of dangers of elevated TVs that are larger, heavier 3