PITTSBURGH, March 15 How can a dying patient's family members and physicians get along when faced with difficult decisions on end-of-life treatment? The medical and emotional issues surrounding the care of a dying patient are both stressful and complicated, as highlighted in this week's Journal of the American Medical Association Clinician's Corner Perspectives on Care at the Close of Life, which highlights the case of an 84-year-old woman with advanced dementia whose advance directive states that she does not want artificial nutrition or hydration. Over the course of her illness, her family and physicians conflict about the use of a short-term feeding tube and intravenous hydration.
From this case study, authors Robert M. Arnold M.D., Leo H. Criep chair in patient care, professor of medicine, and chief, section of palliative care and medical ethics at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine along with Anthony L. Back, M.D., an oncologist and medical ethicist from the University of Washington, Seattle sought ways to identify conflict and make recommendations on how to avoid the pitfalls and recognize disputes by employing useful communication tools.
"Physicians often assume that conflict is a bad thing and something that should be avoided, yet conflict handled well can be productive and the clarity that results can lead to clearer decision making and greater satisfaction," says Dr. Arnold.
The five major types of conflict the authors identified include physician-family conflict, physician-nurse conflict, physician-physician conflict, family-family conflict and physician-patient conflict.
In the physician-family conflict scenario, family members may have concerns that hospitals do not respect their roles as caregivers, that they do not get the information they need or that the decisions are inconsistent with their wishes.
In the physician-nurse conflict scenario, previous studies in the intensive care unit suggest thPage: 1 2 3 Related medicine news :1
. Dealing with casualties from a terrorist attack2
. Dealing with death3
. Physician response to conflicts between faith and medicine4
. Physicians response to religion-related conflicts in medicine5
. Examination of possible conflicts of interest to influence look at suspected adverse drug reactions6
. Health and politics: Lessons learned from the Iraq conflict7
. Ten percent of employees experience work-family conflict8
. Joint-custody arrangements good for children of divorce -- but only if there is no parental conflict9
. Leading NIH-funded medical schools agree on guidelines that would strenghten conflict of interest policies10
. Emotional support during conflict situations elevates blood pressure in African-American boys11
. Enhanced counseling eases depression among people caring for a loved one with Alzheimers disease