HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Disease testing for immigrants: Discrimination disguised as public health policy

Policies that deny visas to prospective immigrants on the basis of disease are discriminatory, designed to seize on public fears, and do not protect public health, states an editorial in this week's issue of The Lancet.

Last week, UK opposition-party leader Michael Howard announced that his party would deny visas to prospective immigrants who test positive for tuberculosis (TB). HIV tests would also be mandatory under the Conservative policy, but visas would not necessarily be withheld. This plan, says Howard, is a strategy to minimise the public-health threats posed by immigrants. But the intense debate these proposals have generated-mainly because of their similarity to current government policies-has unfortunately obscured a more important point: that disease must not be a basis for discrimination, writes The Lancet.

In the UK, migration has been blamed for a steady increase in newly diagnosed HIV infections, but absolute numbers remain small. Percentage calculations, such as those cited in Howard's publicity material, exaggerate the relative burden of immigration-related illness. According to the Health Protection Agency's most recent report, the number of newly diagnosed HIV infections thought to have been contracted outside the UK in 2003 number only around 3000.

Reacting to public fears over perceived threats, countries including Canada, USA, Australia, and New Zealand, have adopted stringent policies for compulsory screening of new entrants for TB and HIV. But the only UK public inquiry into the issue came out firmly against the idea, concluding that "there is no evidence to suggest that such a policy would be effective at protecting public health". The All Party Parliamentary Group on AIDS, which set up the inquiry, expressed grave concerns that the government was seeking ways to "exclude vulnerable individuals on the basis of poor health".

The Lancet comments: "Policies that discriminate against visa applican
'"/>

Contact: Udani Samarasekera
pressoffice@lancet.com
44-207-424-4949
Lancet
24-Feb-2005


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. 2005 Basic Research in Periodontal Disease Award
2. The Larry King Cardiac Foundation presents The Changing Face of Heart Disease on Feb. 2
3. Study finds lemons, lilac among top 10 smells that predict Alzheimers Disease
4. New studies on Ritalin and Alzheimers Disease highlight ACNP Annual Meeting
5. University seeks recruits for Parkinsons Disease study
6. 2004 Research in Periodontal Disease Award to Soskolne
7. Robert Wood Johnson Medical School researcher receives fellowship for work in Canavan Disease
8. Northwestern named Udall Center for Parkinsons Disease Research
9. The Lancet Infectious Diseases (TLID)
10. The Lancet Oncology (TLO) and the Lancet Infectious Diseases (TLID)
11. UCSDs Victor Nizet, M.D., receives Pediatric Infectious Diseases Award

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:9/17/2019)... , ... September 17, 2019 , ... ... availability of the newly updated International Audit Protocol Consortium (IAPC) EHS audit protocol ... protocols to understand the scope of their EHS regulatory obligations and rapidly collect, ...
(Date:9/14/2019)... ... September 13, 2019 , ... ... studies on the detection and treatment of infectious diseases at its annual ... studies were noninvasive detection of residual HIV infected cell persistence and the ...
(Date:9/11/2019)... , ... September 11, 2019 , ... A September 2 ... had undergone weight loss surgery were significantly less likely to suffer heart attacks, strokes, ... not undergo bariatric surgery. Los Angeles-based weight loss surgery specialists Dr. Feiz and Associates ...
(Date:9/11/2019)... ... , ... Autopsies don’t lie. They report the causes of death as ... harms the heart. It increases risks of heart attack and death. Autopsies ... damage occurs. , An August 1, 2019 article in U.S. News ...
(Date:9/11/2019)... (PRWEB) , ... September 10, 2019 , ... ... to the team. Dr. Hesano is an understanding, caring and highly skilled Obstetrician/Gynecologist. ... high-risk obstetrical medicine. Dr. Hesano strives to ensure that each visit is comfortable, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/17/2019)... Calif. (PRWEB) , ... September 17, 2019 , ... Summer is a time for barbecues, ... is good for our teeth and gums. Dr. Douglas Ng, family dentist in San ... weather is the time for ice cream, and popsicles and ice-filled cold drinks to go ...
(Date:9/14/2019)... ... 13, 2019 , ... Corey Stern , a partner at Levy Konigsberg, ... Archibald over at least 3 decades while employed by Rockefeller University Hospital (“RUH”). ... Court - Southern District of New York, No. 1:19-cv-01403), the first case filed against ...
(Date:9/14/2019)... ... September 14, 2019 , ... On ... with peritoneal mesothelioma, a jury in Middlesex County found Johnson & Johnson liable ... alleging their mesotheliomas were caused by asbestos-containing J&J talc products. , ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: