HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Doctors steer sick patients away from capitated HMOs

Quality concerns drive inadvertent 'cherry picking'

Many doctors unwittingly are helping managed care plans cherry pick healthier patients, while sicker patients are being steered toward safety-net providers, according to a new study.

In a national survey of 787 physicians, 40 percent reported encouraging patients who are sicker or who have more complex illnesses to avoid capitated managed care plans, in which doctors receive a flat monthly rate per patient. At the same time, 23 percent reported encouraging healthier patients to join such plans, finds the study published in the January issue of the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

Although the data dont clearly identify whether it is cost or quality considerations alone that motivate them to make such recommendations, the study shows that physicians are contributing to risk selection among capitated managed care plans, raising legal, ethical and policy issues, according to author Matthew K. Wynia, M.D., M.P.H., of the American Medical Associations Institute for Ethics.

On the one hand, medical leaders have suggested that physicians ought to help their patients make [health plan] selections, because assisting patients in this way is an important form of physician advocacy, the authors note.

Unfortunately, this study shows that even well-intentioned physician advice may foster risk selection, say Wynia and colleagues. Risk selection undermines insurance pools by causing disproportionate enrollment of less costly patients into certain health plans. This is expensive for some payers, who overcompensate health plans with healthier-than-expected enrollees and financially risky for providers who do not or cannot risk-select, such as safety net providers.

Physicians also were asked whether they felt capitated payment plans undermined their ability to offer a quality of care equal to that of other types of managed care reimbursement. One-third of the surveyed
'"/>

Contact: Ross Fraser
312-464-4443
Center for the Advancement of Health
12-Jan-2002


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Doctors need to prepare for blood shortages now
2. Doctors must consider potentially inappropriate medications when treating elderly
3. Doctors transplant ovary to womans arm to preserve fertility
4. Doctors can improve colorectal cancer screening rates
5. Doctors miss chances to provide diet, exercise counseling to patients at risk of heart disease
6. Doctors and patients call on politicians to save lives of cancer patients
7. Doctors dont agree on diagnosis of uterine cancer
8. Doctors at Northwestern Memorial are studying next generation surgery for back pain sufferers
9. U-M study: Doctors more likely to prescribe pricey new blood pressure drugs
10. Doctors over-estimate survival of terminally ill patients
11. Doctors are often strongly affected by patient deaths

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Doctors steer sick patients away from capitated HMOs

(Date:10/25/2014)... The global HCIT outsourcing market is ... reach $50.4 billion by 2018 from $35 billion in ... pharmaceutical industry are driving the HCIT outsourcing market. These ... focus on core business, reduce operational and maintenance costs, ... reducing hiring and training costs), share risk, and quickly ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... 25, 2014 TASC (Total Administrative ... other benefits account management services, announces the release ... save on taxes, reduce administrative workload, and lessen ... savings and the efficient handling of complex, time-sensitive, ... that best meets their goals and objectives. The ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... October 25, 2014 Homeowners that are ... ‘gone bad’ need wonder no more. Clean Crawls ... should watch out for when it comes to insulation ... to the article released by Clean Crawls, can cause ... that any insulation that has deteriorated, become damp, or ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... -- Interrupting blood supply to an arm or a leg ... the surgery, according to a new study. "During ... the heart to be able to operate on it. After ... ability to produce energy because it doesn,t get oxygen. When ... such as an arm or a leg, the body prepares ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... 2014 (HealthDay News) -- A large influx of international ... to avoid tens of thousands of deaths from the ... predict. Using a specially designed mathematical model, ... outbreak in just one densely populated county of hard-hit ... of Monrovia. The researchers said that if international ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Global HCIT Outsourcing Market to Grow at 7.6% CAGR to 2018 Says a Premium Research Report Available at ReportsnReports.com 2Health News:Global HCIT Outsourcing Market to Grow at 7.6% CAGR to 2018 Says a Premium Research Report Available at ReportsnReports.com 3Health News:Global HCIT Outsourcing Market to Grow at 7.6% CAGR to 2018 Says a Premium Research Report Available at ReportsnReports.com 4Health News:TASC’s New Suites Offer Tax Savings and Protection 2Health News:5 Signs Indicating That Insulation Needs Replacing as Told By Clean Crawls in Recent Article 2Health News:Brief Interruption of Blood Supply to Limb Might Aid Heart Surgery: Study 2Health News:Experts Predict 'Catastrophic' Ebola Epidemic in West Africa if Aid Delayed 2
(Date:10/25/2014)... 2014 Research and Markets ... the "Global and Chinese Hemodialysis Concentrates Industry ...      (Logo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20130307/600769) , Global ... a professional and in-depth study on the current ... focus on the Chinese situation. The ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... 2014  In 2008, two of Dr. Gurney,s employees ... controlled substances, on a regular basis, that were not ... Gurney was practicing "all the time" while under the ... employees said that Dr. Gurney was prone to "making ... Dr. Gurney,s behavior became increasingly erratic and unfocused, ...
(Date:10/25/2014)... CUPERTINO, Calif. , Oct. 24, 2014 ... ) third quarter 2014 financial results press release, you ... will be broadcast live over the internet on Monday, ... pm Pacific Time). A live audio webcast ... homepage at http://www.durect.com and clicking "Investor Relations."  ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Global and Chinese Hemodialysis Concentrates Industry Report 2014 2Global and Chinese Hemodialysis Concentrates Industry Report 2014 3Doctors That Harm: The Real Stories Insurance Companies Against Prop 46 Don't Want You To Know, Part 8 of Consumer Watchdog Campaign Series 2Doctors That Harm: The Real Stories Insurance Companies Against Prop 46 Don't Want You To Know, Part 8 of Consumer Watchdog Campaign Series 3DURECT Corporation Invites You to Join its Third Quarter 2014 Earnings Conference Call 2
Cached News: