HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Doctors steer sick patients away from capitated HMOs

Quality concerns drive inadvertent 'cherry picking'

Many doctors unwittingly are helping managed care plans cherry pick healthier patients, while sicker patients are being steered toward safety-net providers, according to a new study.

In a national survey of 787 physicians, 40 percent reported encouraging patients who are sicker or who have more complex illnesses to avoid capitated managed care plans, in which doctors receive a flat monthly rate per patient. At the same time, 23 percent reported encouraging healthier patients to join such plans, finds the study published in the January issue of the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

Although the data dont clearly identify whether it is cost or quality considerations alone that motivate them to make such recommendations, the study shows that physicians are contributing to risk selection among capitated managed care plans, raising legal, ethical and policy issues, according to author Matthew K. Wynia, M.D., M.P.H., of the American Medical Associations Institute for Ethics.

On the one hand, medical leaders have suggested that physicians ought to help their patients make [health plan] selections, because assisting patients in this way is an important form of physician advocacy, the authors note.

Unfortunately, this study shows that even well-intentioned physician advice may foster risk selection, say Wynia and colleagues. Risk selection undermines insurance pools by causing disproportionate enrollment of less costly patients into certain health plans. This is expensive for some payers, who overcompensate health plans with healthier-than-expected enrollees and financially risky for providers who do not or cannot risk-select, such as safety net providers.

Physicians also were asked whether they felt capitated payment plans undermined their ability to offer a quality of care equal to that of other types of managed care reimbursement. One-third of the surveyed
'"/>

Contact: Ross Fraser
312-464-4443
Center for the Advancement of Health
12-Jan-2002


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Doctors need to prepare for blood shortages now
2. Doctors must consider potentially inappropriate medications when treating elderly
3. Doctors transplant ovary to womans arm to preserve fertility
4. Doctors can improve colorectal cancer screening rates
5. Doctors miss chances to provide diet, exercise counseling to patients at risk of heart disease
6. Doctors and patients call on politicians to save lives of cancer patients
7. Doctors dont agree on diagnosis of uterine cancer
8. Doctors at Northwestern Memorial are studying next generation surgery for back pain sufferers
9. U-M study: Doctors more likely to prescribe pricey new blood pressure drugs
10. Doctors over-estimate survival of terminally ill patients
11. Doctors are often strongly affected by patient deaths

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Doctors steer sick patients away from capitated HMOs

(Date:7/31/2014)... 2014 Current residents at Back2Basics ... in Flagstaff, AZ, learn to kayak safely for the ... paddle strokes in preparation for next week's wilderness therapy ... that [the kayaking course] teaches [residents] to listen and ... in their early part of their sobriety," said ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... 31, 2014 Parker Waichman, LLP, a ... cases, comments that whistleblowers are a critical component of ... activities that may cause harm to consumers and may ... Whistleblower Appreciation Day. , According to a 2013 report ... Senate declared "National Whistleblower Appreciation Day" on July 30, ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... (PRWEB) July 31, 2014 To further ... like to provide the following safety information regarding leaving ... a car can have deadly consequences. Because a child’s ... than those of adults, leaving children alone in a ... injury, and even death. , Statistics of Children Left ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... Two years in the making, Becoming ... of the research behind the latest scientific findings on ... Vesanto Melina, well-respected authorities on plant-based nutrition, put forth ... and adequate for people at all stages of life, ... and pregnant or lactating women. , Well-planned is ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... 31, 2014 According to a ... , Endo International, one of several manufacturing companies that ... transvaginal claims for $830 million (in re: American Medical ... No. 2325). Melinda Helbock, Founder of The Law Office ... the settlement and is pleased to see litigation moving ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Back2Basics Substance Abuse Residents Take Kayaking Class for the First Time 2Health News:National Whistleblower Appreciation Day Declared to Ensure Recognition of Enormous Contribution to the Democracy by Whistleblowers, Parker Waichman LLP Comments 2Health News:National Whistleblower Appreciation Day Declared to Ensure Recognition of Enormous Contribution to the Democracy by Whistleblowers, Parker Waichman LLP Comments 3Health News:National Whistleblower Appreciation Day Declared to Ensure Recognition of Enormous Contribution to the Democracy by Whistleblowers, Parker Waichman LLP Comments 4Health News:The Rothenberg Law Firm LLP Teams Up with Local Philadelphia TV Stations to Promote Awareness of the Dangers of Leaving Children Unattended in a Hot Vehicle 2Health News:The Rothenberg Law Firm LLP Teams Up with Local Philadelphia TV Stations to Promote Awareness of the Dangers of Leaving Children Unattended in a Hot Vehicle 3Health News:New Book Presents Health Professionals With A Fully-Referenced, Meticulous Overview of the Research on Plant-Based Diets As A Healthy Choice 2Health News:New Book Presents Health Professionals With A Fully-Referenced, Meticulous Overview of the Research on Plant-Based Diets As A Healthy Choice 3Health News:San Diego Product Liability Firm Provides Commentary on the Latest Developments in Transvaginal Mesh Litigation 2
(Date:7/31/2014)...  UBM Medica US announces that Cancer ... presents exclusive slide shows dealing with communication in the ... care. Cancer Network, the online ... blogs, and podcasts about the latest clinical findings. Among ... , End-of-life care is challenging for even the ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... July 31, 2014 Touro University California,s College ... selected as the recipient of a $150,000 grant by ... the University to increase research and classroom space on ... technology for the study of health sciences, and will ... needs and interests of our students," said Shelley ...
(Date:7/31/2014)... 31, 2014  Cannabis Science, Inc. (OTC-QB: CBIS), ... development and related consulting, is pleased to announce ... of cannabis and European Union certified hemp varieties ... strains for development of proprietary formulations for clinical ... market for critical ailments such as cancer and ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Cancer Network Highlights Methods Oncologists Can Use to Improve Communication 2Cancer Network Highlights Methods Oncologists Can Use to Improve Communication 3Touro University California Garners Grant From Long Foundation 2Cannabis Science Initiates Scientific Cultivation Programs to Test Multiple Strains of Cannabis to Obtain Extract Formulations for Clinical Drug Development Targeting Multiple Critical Ailments Starting with Cancer and Neurological Disorders 2
Cached News: