HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Document destruction practices obliterate tobacco company defenses in critical Australian decision

McCabe v. BAT
An Australian grandmother dying from lung cancer and suing British American Tobacco (BAT) was awarded $700,000 (Australian or about $375,000 US) by a Melbourne jury. The jury only considered the amount of damages and not any liability questions because the trial judge found that BAT's document destruction activities made a fair trial impossible.

CASE BACKGROUND
Rolah Ann McCabe is a 51-year old woman suffering from the advanced stages of lung cancer. Her lawsuit sought compensatory, pain and suffering, and punitive damages against British American Tobacco Australia Services Limited (formerly WD and HO Wills), the Australian subsidiary of tobacco giant BAT. She smoked Escort and Capstan brands. Ms. McCabe alleged that BAT Australia, itself or through its predecessor and affiliated companies, knew that cigarettes were addictive and dangerous to health, and by its advertising targeted children to become consumers. She charged that BAT Australia, knowing the dangers of addiction and to health of consumers, took no reasonable steps to reduce or eliminate the risk of addiction or the health risks, and ignored or publicly disparaged research results that indicated the dangers to health of smoking.

Ms. McCabe allowed her punitive damages claims to be voluntarily dismissed because her health was such that she might not survive to the end of the trial were those additional claims to be presented. Had she died prior to the jury's verdict, monetary recovery would have been substantially reduced under Australian law. Due to the circumstances of the case, one can only assume that she would have likely succeeded had those claims gone to the jury.

The trial was held in the Supreme Court of Victoria at Melbourne with Justice Geoffrey Eames presiding. After four hours of deliberation, the jury returned its verdict in favor of Ms. McCabe.

Document Destruction Sanctions
The plaintiff's attorney (known as a barris
'"/>

Contact: Christine Phelan
c.phelan@neu.edu
617-373-5455
Northeastern University
11-Apr-2002


Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Studies yield key insights in preventing destruction of insulin-producing cells
2. Prostate cancer screening practices examined
3. NJIT chemistry professor edits text outlining best laboratory practices
4. Branding practices in rural India should be banned
5. Certain gun storage practices can reduce risk of youth firearm injuries, suicide
6. A penny a month could bolster kids immunization practices
7. AAPA survey shows physician assistants increasingly employed in medical practices
8. Latest child neurology practices and studies presented at daylong briefing
9. Physicians and dentists play important role in smoking practices of the elderly
10. Maternal feeding practices are linked to childhood obesity
11. Hartford Institute sponsors SNAPP initiative to bring best practices to non-geriatric nurses

Post Your Comments:
(Date:7/22/2014)... says women are often in the dark. Historically, it was ... has shown that post-menopausal women are just as likely as ... be adequately diagnosed and treated. New research from Western University ... Clinical Pharmacology brings to light a genetic basis for ... are more prone to heart disease. , The study, led ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... July 22, 2014 As reported on July ... caller request to name her favorite beauty products, “ Botox ... to say that “ Botox has changed my life” ... makeup chair preparing for her various, daily appearances. “Suddenly ... Ms. Ripa (see: goo.gl/shmTQM). , “I think that Kelly Ripa’s ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... New guidelines on cholesterol treatment and cardiovascular risk assessment ... of dying from atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease or of having ... a similar risk profile (based on age, smoking history, ... this finding for when and how aggressively to treat ... Journal of Men,s Health , a peer-reviewed publication from ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... Ticket Down is a reliable source for ... Field in Landover, MD. There has never been a better ... soccer. After the success of the American national soccer team at ... well. One way that fans of the world’s sport will be ... 2014 Guinness International Champions Cup. The tournament will kick off on ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... The park is the heart of ... Homeowners Association, Inc., made a recent investment in ... the purchase of playground equipment from American Parks Company™. ... Miami Florida, and is a 475-unit community that was ... landscape has created a tropical paradise with lush shade ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Gene variant identified as a heart disease risk factor for women 2Health News:Celebrity Botox: Kelly Ripa Confesses to Getting Botox Injections 2Health News:Manchester United vs. Inter Milan Tickets Fedex Field Landover: Ticket Down Slashes Ticket Prices for Inter Milan ManU International Champions Cup Match in Washington, DC 2Health News:Manchester United vs. Inter Milan Tickets Fedex Field Landover: Ticket Down Slashes Ticket Prices for Inter Milan ManU International Champions Cup Match in Washington, DC 3Health News:Fun in the Florida Sun: Kendalltown Homeowners Association Inc. Expands Outdoor Recreation with American Parks Company™ 2Health News:Fun in the Florida Sun: Kendalltown Homeowners Association Inc. Expands Outdoor Recreation with American Parks Company™ 3
(Date:7/22/2014)... England , July 22, 2014 Elekta ... announced today that The Christie NHS Foundation Trust ( ... will join a consortium whose mission is to develop ... (MRI) guided radiation therapy system. Such a system would, ... visualization of cancer targets. "The Christie ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... 2014 Galmed Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (Nasdaq: ... the development and commercialization of a once-daily, oral therapy ... announced today that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, ... IND, application.  Such clearance will permit Galmed to conduct ... the United States for the treatment ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... July 22, 2014 The steady decline ... spreading to previously rep-friendly specialties, according to the ... marketing consulting firm ZS Associates.      ... U.S. pharmaceutical sales teams. The report examines how ... with the pharmaceutical sales reps who visit their ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:The Christie Hospital joins Elekta and Philips research consortium to develop MRI-guided radiation therapy system for cancer treatment 2The Christie Hospital joins Elekta and Philips research consortium to develop MRI-guided radiation therapy system for cancer treatment 3The Christie Hospital joins Elekta and Philips research consortium to develop MRI-guided radiation therapy system for cancer treatment 4Galmed Announces FDA Clearance of IND of Armachol for the Treatment of Fatty Liver Disorders 2Galmed Announces FDA Clearance of IND of Armachol for the Treatment of Fatty Liver Disorders 3Galmed Announces FDA Clearance of IND of Armachol for the Treatment of Fatty Liver Disorders 4Even traditionally rep-friendly specialists will see fewer pharmaceutical sales reps this year, according to ZS Associates 2Even traditionally rep-friendly specialists will see fewer pharmaceutical sales reps this year, according to ZS Associates 3Even traditionally rep-friendly specialists will see fewer pharmaceutical sales reps this year, according to ZS Associates 4Even traditionally rep-friendly specialists will see fewer pharmaceutical sales reps this year, according to ZS Associates 5
Cached News: