Evidence for shaken baby syndrome is uncertain

The concept that certain eye injuries are diagnostic of shaken baby syndrome is scientifically questionable and needs to be re-examined, argue researchers in this week's BMJ.

Shaken baby syndrome is a term used to describe the consequences of the forceful shaking of infants. It is usually recognised by a triad of injuries - bleeding into the eye and around the brain (subdural and retinal haemorrhages) and brain damage.

Patrick Lantz and colleagues report the case of a healthy 14 month old child who was brought to hospital with a severe head injury after a television fell on him at home.

Despite the father's repeated, detailed, and consistent account of the incident, Child Protective Services removed the child's 3 year old brother from the home because the injuries, particularly those in the retina of the eye (known as perimacular retinal folds), were considered diagnostic of abusive head trauma from shaking.

The authors searched the medical literature on the eye injury observed in this case that has been considered specific for child abuse. They found that the ocular criteria used by some doctors to diagnose shaken baby syndrome "are not supported by objective scientific evidence" when taken out of context.

Their findings are remarkably similar to another recently published review of the literature from 1966 to 1998, which identified "serious data gaps" in the scientific evidence to support a diagnosis of shaken baby syndrome.

In an accompanying editorial, experts stress the need to reconsider the diagnostic criteria, if not the existence, of shaken baby syndrome. A second editorial argues that no one detail can be diagnostic, as the diagnosis of shaken baby syndrome should rest on a careful evaluation of all the features of the injury.

There are clearly many uncertainties relating to shaken baby syndrome, and the scientific evidence to support a diagnosis may be less reliable than generally thought. These is

Contact: Emma Dickinson
BMJ-British Medical Journal

Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Evidence indicates cancer patients unable to intentionally postpone death for significant events
2. Not guilty! Evidence exonerates 328, but many still falsely imprisoned
3. Evidence suggests that the brain can switch to automatic pilot during learning
4. Evidence that memories are consolidated during sleep
5. Evidence that neurons prune only twigs to rewire themselves
6. Evidence supports two types of heart failure
7. Evidence for warts treatments is weak
8. Evidence does not support psychological treatments for epilepsy
9. Evidence of PSA screening efficacy lacking
10. DDW Studies Present Evidence That Thalomid (Thalidomide) Is Active In Treating Crohns Disease
11. Evidence Shows Drug-Psychotherapy Combo Effective For Chronic Depression

Post Your Comments:

(Date:7/31/2020)... ... July 31, 2020 , ... Today Hinge Health, ... expansion of clinical & technical capabilities to cover the full continuum of care ... joint health solution. , Currently, employers interested in truly solving their MSK ...
(Date:7/22/2020)... ... July 22, 2020 , ... Whatever we call them – sunspots, age spots, ... summer glow,” notes Angie Seelal, a Certified Registered Physician Assistant specializing in Dermatology with ... years later and make us look older.” , In terms of the name, ‘sunspots’ ...
(Date:7/22/2020)... ... July 22, 2020 , ... With Covid-19 and the racial ... has changed, and there’s no going back. In confronting our discomfort during 2020, ... temporarily manage emotional struggles, healing is the approach we should strive for. Lasting ...
(Date:7/22/2020)... ... July 22, 2020 , ... Sun ... for patients and staff. These measures include partnering with industry infectious disease ... timely response is based on guidance from the Centers for Disease Control ...
(Date:7/18/2020)... ... July 17, 2020 , ... A June 2 article on Daily Mail reported ... for her mishandled breast augmentations. The article says that her first procedure, unbeknownst to her, ... woman then found a surgeon to revise her procedure, only to find out the doctor ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/7/2020)... ... August 07, 2020 , ... Glewed TV, a leading video-on-demand ... video content, today announced a partnership with award-winning director Charles Mattocks to air ... patients. The first reality TV series of its kind, Eight Days first aired ...
(Date:8/5/2020)... ... ... In an informal poll of 150 fans, conducted by long-time Twins fan Charles ... and Paul” logo that is more racially and culturally sensitive and inclusive. The original ... rights movement in the United States. The Minnesota Twins have never updated their logo, ...
(Date:8/5/2020)... FALLS CHURCH, Va. (PRWEB) , ... ... ... Your Risk-Based Cleaning and Disinfectant Programs: , Best Practices During COVID-19, An ... , The task of maintaining a controlled cleanroom is never simple ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: