HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Fair decisions more important when hospitals face crisis like SARS

But international medical ethics specialists (appendix 1) who evaluated the performance of one large Toronto area hospital during last year's SARS outbreak conclude that procedural requirements, particularly fair and ethical priority-setting, are even more important in the midst of a crisis.

"Hospitals operate at their best when staff and patients trust the process," says Doug Martin, PhD, who led the study for the University of Toronto Joint Centre for Bioethics (JCB). "But the SARS outbreak raised questions that many hospital administrators and staff had never faced before."

The study group identified a number of decision-making difficulties affecting both SARS and non-SARS patients.

Among them:

  • To what extent should the need to contain the outbreak override other important needs? In early stages of the outbreak, the hospital suspended all surgery and banned visitations, causing considerable hardship to the most seriously ill non-SARS patients and their families; and

  • To what extent should the need for quick decisions override the need for legitimate and fair decision making? Upon resumption of normal hospital operations, there was considerable pressure to move quickly to ease the surgical backlog.

    The group's report, published today by U.K.-based Biomed Central, concludes that "in the midst of a crisis such as SARS where guidance is incomplete, consequences uncertain and information constantly changing, where hour-by-hour decisions involve life and death, fairness is more important rather than less."

    The hospital's decision making practices were evaluated using the "accountability for reasonableness" ethical framework, developed by the JCB to guide fair priority setting in health care organizations. Under this framework, an institution's priority setting is judged fair if four conditions are met:

  • Relevance: Rationales for priority setting decisions must rest on rea
    '"/>


    • Contact: Terry Collins
    terrycollins@rogers.com
    416-538-8712
    University of Toronto Joint Center for Bioethics
    19-Dec-2004


    Page: 1 2 3 4

    Related medicine news :

    1. Balancing care decisions for gravely ill patients
    2. How the stories of ordinary people could give them more say over planning decisions
    3. Web-based tool to help clinicians make schizophrenia treatment decisions
    4. Concerns about fertility affect treatment decisions in one-third of young breast cancer patients
    5. European study highlights frequency of medical end-of-life decisions in terminally ill pts
    6. Brain imaging study reveals interplay of thought and emotion in economic decisions
    7. Peer pressure matters in young adults smoking decisions
    8. Computerized tool predicts sarcoma outcome and improves ability to make better treatment decisions
    9. Genetics important in age-related macular degeneration
    10. Reducing hostility in young coronary artery disease patients is important piece of rehabilitation
    11. Molecule important in cell construction also critical in learning and memory

    Post Your Comments:
    *Name:
    *Comment:
    *Email:
    		TAG: Fair decisions more important when hospitals face crisis like SARS

    (Date:3/7/2014)... study from St. Michael,s Hospital found that, after ... coming into Ontario emergency departments with suicide-related behaviours ... behaviours are incidents of self-inflicted injuries or self-poisonings. ... Evaluative Sciences, the researchers found that from 2002 ... Ontario emergency departments with suicide-related behaviours declined by ...
    (Date:3/7/2014)... lens could possibly make life easier for some of the ... and a runny nose as soon as the pollen season ... newly developed Danish mini-filter - Rhinix - appears to be ... than a filterless placebo., The study has just been published ... . , Filter blocks pollen , The filter, which ...
    (Date:3/7/2014)... testing for those men most at risk of prostate ... whole population, a leading scientist from The University of ... has argued at an international conference this week. , ... blood test for prostate cancer once they reach the ... a prostate biopsy if their PSA level is greater ...
    (Date:3/7/2014)... die younger than older mothers but raise bigger families ... University of Sheffield. , Experts from the University,s ... lives of 416 Asian elephant mothers in Myanmar, Burma, ... of 19 were almost two times more likely to ... had their first offspring later. , However, elephants that ...
    (Date:3/6/2014)... rates breathing difficulties on a scale of 0 to ... a study published in the March issue of ... And although a poor score means a higher risk ... spot lung involvement early means that patients can begin ... Stephanie Lee, M.D., M.P.H., research director of Fred Hutchinson ...
    Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:After years of improving, rates of youth suicide-related behaviors stopped declining 2Health News:Danish nasal filter looks promising for allergy sufferers 2Health News:New approach to prostate cancer screening needed 2Health News:Teen elephant mothers die younger but have bigger families, University of Sheffield research finds 2Health News:Early detection helps manage a chronic graft-vs.-host disease complication 2
    (Date:1/14/2014)... NineSigma , Inc., the leading innovation ... Leadership Summit , May 14-16, 2014 at the Global ... . This is the premier ... breakthrough achievements through open innovation. Participants will learn how ... disciplines and even across industries. NineSigma ...
    (Date:1/14/2014)... WASHINGTON, New York , January 14, ... http://www.equashield.com ), the leading provider of Closed System Transfer Devices (CSTD) ... has achieved 60% year-over-year sales growth for ... Equashield,s closed systems reduce the risk of ... other medical professionals who prepare and administer ...
    (Date:1/14/2014)... -- Spark Therapeutics , a late-stage gene therapy company, ... clinical program, a Phase 3 study for inherited retinal dystrophies ... CEO, Jeffrey D. Marrazzo , is presenting this and ... Healthcare Conference in San Francisco . Marrazzo ... year after the study,s initiation and anticipates filing a BLA ...
    Breaking Medicine Technology:Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 2Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 3Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 4Equashield's Sales Grow by 60% in 2013 2Spark Therapeutics Achieves Recruitment Goal in Phase 3 Gene Therapy Clinical Study for Inherited Blindness 2Spark Therapeutics Achieves Recruitment Goal in Phase 3 Gene Therapy Clinical Study for Inherited Blindness 3
    Cached News: