HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
'Fatally flawed' legal analysis will not stand

Washington DC (November 18, 2004) Legal scholars advising the Alliance for Taxpayer Access quickly dismissed the faulty analysis made by the American Physiological Society's outside counsel suggesting the National Institutes of Health's public access plan will infringe copyright claims of grantees and publishers. [The claims were included in the APS comments filed with the NIH this week.]

In rebuttal, intellectual property expert Michael Carroll stressed that the NIH proposed policy is "completely consistent with the scope of NIH's license and mission," and labeled the APS analysis a "fatally flawed house of cards."

Serving as adviser to the Alliance for Taxpayer Access, Carroll is an expert on intellectual property and Internet law, and teaches on the law faculty at Villanova University School of Law.

According to Professor Carroll, "The publishers acknowledge that NIH has always had license to reproduce, publish and archive the research results that it has paid for. It is explicit; there is no question about that."

"Their analysis is built on the false premise that NIH is making a change to copyright law. The fact is, in all cases, NIH grantees must give NIH a royalty-free, nonexclusive, and irrevocable license for the Federal government to 'reproduce, publish, or otherwise use' the material and to authorize others to do so for Federal purpose. Nothing in this proposal alters the terms of NIH's license and consequently, copyright law is not an obstacle for the NIH to move forward. Most of the APS counsel's other arguments rely on this misunderstanding of copyright law, and therefore, are inapplicable."

"Nothing could be more consistent with the federal purpose of NIH than collecting this research in an archive and allowing taxpayers and follow-on researchers to have access to the fruits of their NIH investment."

Rick Johnson, director of the Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition added, "These 1
'"/>

Contact: Glynnis Breen
gbreen@witeckcombs.com
202-887-0500
Witeck Combs
19-Nov-2004


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Illegal drug use causes painful complications for oncology patients
2. Halloween can be dangerous for those wearing illegal costume contact lenses
3. Is legalising euthanasia premature?
4. Emory gathers global experts to address business and legal challenges of HIV/AIDS fight
5. Underage smokers respond to threat of legal penalties
6. It is easy for adolescents to purchase cigarettes illegally in North Carolina
7. New system for the analysis of facial movement in three dimensions
8. Re-analysis of large trials shows greatest benefit of chemotherapy in ER-negative tumors
9. Subanalysis finds patient-controlled, transdermal pain management system may be comparable
10. New analysis links breastfeeding to reduced risk of childhood leukemia
11. Calling for standards in cardiology data collection and analysis

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:8/11/2018)... ... 10, 2018 , ... TopConsumerReviews.com recently awarded a five-star rating ... This painful, persistent condition originates in the liver and is characterized by pain ... Other contributing factors may be medication side effects, overweight, and unhealthy diet. The ...
(Date:8/9/2018)... ... August 09, 2018 , ... Thousands ... have ruptured, according to cross-referenced data from The American Society of Plastic Surgeons ... rupture rates monitored by the FDA. As an MRI is recommended by FDA ...
(Date:8/9/2018)... , ... August 09, 2018 , ... ... been engaged as an Operating Partner and will have an exclusive relationship with ... role in the firm’s strategic planning, human capital sourcing, and deal origination, evaluation ...
(Date:8/7/2018)... ... August 07, 2018 , ... Today Springfield Creamery added six ... rich, cream-on-top-style yogurts are made with milk from grass-fed cows who enjoy a ... fatty acids. Nancy’s sources the milk from organic family-owned farms, all within 60 ...
(Date:8/3/2018)... ... 2018 , ... Yisrayl Hawkins, Pastor and Overseer at The House of Yahweh, ... the Bible meant only to be understood in this current generation. Yisrayl says he ... decode passages that he says scholars have struggled with for generations. Yisrayl says the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/14/2018)... , ... August 14, 2018 , ... ... Academy, their first-ever summer harvest employment and hands-on educational program developed for students ... in a high school, junior college or university, spent a minimum of 6 ...
(Date:8/11/2018)... ... August 10, 2018 , ... Last month, Dr. Tim Herman, Lead Dentist at ... care in underserved communities surrounding its capital of Asunción. Along with a team of ... his time to help deliver care to over 550 individuals in need. , Outreaches ...
(Date:8/9/2018)... ... ... Autism is a developmental disorder affecting more than 3.5 million Americans’ ability ... 68 people have the disorder), chances are you know someone on the autism spectrum! ... autism methods of communication and tactics to interact with others. These options help set ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: