HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Findings of Griffiths review into allegations of research misconduct fundamentally flawed

Investigating allegations of research misconduct: the vital need for due process

Commentary: Response from members of the Griffiths inquiry

Editorial: Inquiring into inquiries

"Almost every statement made about the design, conduct, and reporting of the neonatal CNEP trial in the Griffiths report was ill informed, misguided, or factually wrong," concludes a review of its findings in this week's BMJ.

The internal review chaired by Professor Rod Griffiths was set up in February 1999 after several parents alleged that their premature babies had been entered into a controlled trial of a breathing support technique, known as continuous negative extrathoracic pressure (CNEP), without their consent. The resulting report was published in May this year.

Dr Edmund Hey, a retired paediatrician from Newcastle upon Tyne, and Dr Iain Chalmers, director of the UK Cochrane Centre in Oxford, conducted their review on behalf of the Medical Defence Union. In their swingeing critique the authors raise serious doubts about the reliability of the report, the review, and the appropriateness of the ensuing recommendations.

The authors defend the trial's design, which, they claim, the panel had failed to understand. They refute the allegation that no external peer review had been conducted and they accuse the panel of making "an unwarranted slur on the professionalism and skill of all the nurses concerned." They say that a consent document existed among the research records for every child in the study. Assertions made by a small number of parents about events up to 10 years ago went unchecked, say the authors, yet now form the basis for recommending major changes to the governance of clinical research in the NHS.

"We can still agree that there has been a scandal, but suspect that the scandal is what has been done to, not what was done by, the medical and nursing staff in Stoke on Trent."

Responding to the crit
'"/>

Contact: Emma Wilkinson
ewilkinson@bmj.com
44-20-7383-6259
BMJ-British Medical Journal
21-Sep-2000


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Findings support shorter course of radiation therapy after breast lumpectomy
2. New Findings On Dopamine Receptor Biology: Implications For Mental Illness
3. New Findings On Asthma And Breastfeeding, Obesity And Asthma And Snoring And Pre-eclampsia At ALA/ATS Meeting
4. Reassuring Findings About Infants Exposed To Zidovudine
5. Worlds Premier Pharmaceutical Scientists Share Latest R&D Findings
6. Experts To Discuss Findings From New Lewin Group Study In Conference Call Briefing
7. Over 6,000 Technical Presentations Will Reveal New Findings At National Chemists Meeting In Boston, August 23 - 27
8. Major review of subway systems suggests potential for significant health and safety hazards
9. Rebuilding wounded veterans: Annual review of limb loss & prosthetics research
10. Pharmacist review does not keep older people out of hospital
11. Delays in test result reviewing common

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:4/18/2019)... ... 2019 , ... WHAT:, Patients today have more choices and ... of online review sites and healthcare-related searches on the web, patients have come ... decisions online. In order to elevate a health system’s reputation in a competitive ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... April 17, 2019 , ... Kadan Homecare, an award-winning provider of quality, non-medical ... has received both the 2019 Best of Home Care® – Provider of Choice and ... the top-ranking home care providers, based on client and caregiver satisfaction scores gathered by ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... April 17, 2019 , ... Fertility ... April 27), in an effort to unite millions of Americans aiming to remove ... To support this initiative, Fertility Centers of Illinois is offering seven free physician-led ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... , ... April 17, 2019 , ... Signaled.online is a ... available for users: alarm, monitoring of the web resources and reminder. , The alarm ... as if you live alone. If you haven’t logged in to the website for ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... April 17, 2019 , ... Stephen Press B.S., D.M.D. of ... by NJ Top Dentists. Upon graduating from the University of Pittsburgh School of Dental ... he began practicing in the Montclair area. In 1996, Dr. Press opened his NJ ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... ... Women’s Excellence in Obstetrics and Gynecology now offers same day appointments for ... be seen by a provider. We believe in getting patients in right away ... as possible.” Dr. Jonathan Zaidan, MD, FACOG, President of Women’s Excellence. , Women’s Excellence ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... 2019 , ... United Breast Cancer Foundation (UBCF) hosted the incredibly ... April 3rd. Barclays Center, home to the Brooklyn Nets and New York Islanders, is ... Global, which operates and manages Barclays Center, for generously donating space to help facilitate ...
(Date:4/17/2019)... ... , ... Able&Co. is marking its tenth anniversary this year with a move ... growing client list. Located near the airport, the new space at 7920 ACC Boulevard ... environment we always planned,” said Jenny Taylor, President of Able&Co. “Contemporary and reflective of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: