Flu vaccination impact on elderly deaths may be over...( CHICAGO Observational studies which re...),Health

CHICAGO Observational studies which report that influenza vaccination reduces winter mortality risk among the elderly by 50 percent may substantially overestimate the vaccination benefit, according to the February 14 issue of The Archives of Internal Medicine, one of the JAMA/Archives journals.

Accurate determination of the impact of influenza on mortality is difficult because the infection is often cleared before the onset of the secondary complications that actually cause a person's death, according to the article. Although influenza vaccination of the elderly in the U.S. has increased from 15 to 20 percent before 1980 to 65 percent in 2001, the authors could find no correlation between this increasing vaccination coverage after 1980 and declining deaths rates in any age group. Observational studies may introduce a systematic bias that leads to a substantial over-estimate of the impact of influenza vaccination on mortality, the authors suggest.

Lone Simonsen, Ph.D., of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and colleagues, used statistical models that estimate the winter-seasonal all-cause mortality above an estimated baseline to determine influenza-related mortality indirectly. Their model incorporated information on deaths among the elderly from pneumonia and influenza and all other causes from 33 winter seasons from 1968-2001. "Our results, based on national vital statistics, are simply not consistent with the very large mortality benefits reported in observational studies," the authors write. The authors suggest that this disconnect may be explained by a disparity in who is likely to be vaccinated. "Very ill elderly people, whose fragile health would make them highly likely to die over the coming winter months, are less likely to be vaccinated during the autumn vaccination period," they stated.

"Our results have obvious implications for influenza vaccination policy. The present findings, and those of at least one o
'"/>

Contact: Laurie Doepel
301-402-1663
JAMA and Archives Journals
14-Feb-2005

Page: 1 2
Related medicine news :

1. Many children are undervaccinated or have delayed vaccinations in their first 2 years of life
2. Influenza vaccination programmes for children in USA and Canada based on little evidence
3. Flu vaccination benefits people of any age with high-risk medical conditions
4. Risk factors affect parents attitudes about STD vaccinations
5. Parents comfortable with vaccination for sexually transmitted infections for adolescent children
6. Broad-based vaccination of wild mice could help reduce lyme disease risk in humans
7. Study documents decline in rare paralytic disorder linked to influenza vaccination
8. Annual vaccination against influenza associated with decreased risk of death in elderly
9. Hib infections on the rise in adults despite child vaccination programme
10. Most physicians agree that widespread routine influenza vaccination for young children is feasible
11. Childhood vaccination coverage affected by temporary suspension of hepatitis B vaccine