Many Medical Screening Tests May Be Un...( ANN ARBOR---Doctors can face an e...)

Many Medical Screening Tests May Be Unnecessary.

ANN ARBOR---Doctors can face an ethical dilemma when patients request screening tests---such as those for breast cancer and prostate cancer---that may be ill-advised under certain circumstances. A University of Michigan physician and three co-authors explore that predicament in the article "Ethical Considerations in the Provision of Controversial Screening Tests," in the current issue of the Archives of Family Medicine.

Physicians may face this quandary when patients claim entitlement to such tests under their insurance plans, when health advocacy and professional groups recommend their use, or when media attention heightens interest in the latest screening breakthrough, the article notes.

These claims, however, may not be supported by scientific evidence demonstrating that the screening tests meet a minimum criteria of effectiveness.

For example, the article points out that there is considerable disagreement in the medical community over the routine use of mammograms in women under the age of 50 and prostate specific antigen tests in men. The ethical issue becomes more complicated when doctors provide controversial screening tests because they fear a future lawsuit by a patient who later develops a disease.

The article describes several potential risks of screening tests with controversial benefits, including:

Reliance on screening tests before their effectiveness has been corroborated by adequate research.
Creating the impression that such exams can reduce a patient's risk to zero---possibly leading them to make uninformed medical decisions.
Inaccurate, false positive results which can cause profound anxiety and require additional testing that can be increasingly invasive and costly.
Depleting society's limited medical resources.

The article asserts that physicians have a responsibility to inform patients of the limi
'"/>

Contact: David Wilkins or Pete Barkey
wilkins@umich.edu
(313) 764-2220
University of Michigan
16-Oct-1997

Page: 1 2
Related medicine news :

1. Medically supervised drug injection facilities safer for users
2. Medical molecules designed to respond to visible light that can penetrate tissue
3. Philanthropist Paul F. Glenn launches labs for aging research at Harvard Medical School
4. UCLA Medical Center becomes first hospital to introduce remote presence robots in ICU
5. New data on Orqis Medicals Cancion CRS to be reported at ACC
6. Medical technologies may hinder rather than help newborn survival
7. Medical meeting to feature research findings and disease prevention and health promotion sessions
8. LA BioMed Medical/Research briefs January 2005
9. Medical negligence system is secretive, unaccountable and unregulated
10. Dartmouth Medical School receives $1.6 million in AIDS funding
11. LA BioMed Medical/Research Briefs December 2004

Post Your Comments:

(Date:11/23/2009)...hildren who don,t access health care from the same...antly more likely to have unmet health care needs ...ublished in the journal Pediatrics . , Studies...and delivery of quality health care for children, ...y debates about health insurance reform, much of t...

(Date:11/23/2009)... patients who reined in their hypertension, study ...ews) -- High blood pressure is better controlled b...n by doctors and pharmacists working alone, a new ...acists, medications are intensified, dosages incre...ry L. Carter, a professor in the University of Iow...

(Date:11/23/2009)...ityBanksin Washington D.C. , NewYork , N.Y.... IntendedtoSpurEconomicGrowthandRevitalization ...Vita,thenation,sleadingproviderofdialysisservices,...ignedtocreatejobsandspurrevitalizationinminorityco...ommunityandminority-ownedbanks.DaVitahasdonated$5m...

(Date:11/23/2009)...Newswire/--CortivaInstituteTucsonwillhostanIntrodu...p.m.attheschool,s6390EastBroadwayBlvd.location,whi...dpracticebasicmassagestrokes. ,, "Massagetherap...rightalongwithit,"saidJoannMcMaster,presidentofCor...tofLabor,s2009-2010OccupationalOutlookHandbookstat...

(Date:11/23/2009)...breathing, protein may be the cause , , ...ers say they,ve identified a protein that causes ...t of people with chronic sinusitis. , The condi..., a constant irritation and swelling of the nasal ...tissue -- can block the sinus passages and make it...

Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Children who lack continuity with a regular health care provider miss needed services 2 Health News:Children who lack continuity with a regular health care provider miss needed services 3 Health News:Doctor-Pharmacist Teams Boost Blood Pressure Control 2 Health News:Doctor-Pharmacist Teams Boost Blood Pressure Control 3 Health News:DaVita Launches Minority Bank Initiative with $5 Million Investment in Underserved Communities Across the Country 2 Health News:DaVita Launches Minority Bank Initiative with $5 Million Investment in Underserved Communities Across the Country 3 Health News:Cortiva Institute To Host Workshop, Hands-On Opportunity for Prospective Students 2 Health News:Research Yields Clues to Severe Form of Sinusitis 2

[0] Children who lack continuity with a regular health care provider miss needed services [1] Doctor-Pharmacist Teams Boost Blood Pressure Control [0] DaVita Launches Minority Bank Initiative with $5 Million Investment in Underserved Communities Across the Country [1] Cortiva Institute To Host Workshop, Hands-On Opportunity for Prospective Students [0] Research Yields Clues to Severe Form of Sinusitis

(Date:11/23/2009)... SUNNYVALE,Calif.,Nov.23/PRNewswire-FirstCall/--Ac...efieldofradiosurgery,announcedtodaythatitsmanageme...ealthcareConferenceinNewYorkonTuesday,December1,20...tattheJ.P.MorganSmall/MidCapConferenceinNewYorkonT..., Alivewebcastofeachpresentationwillbeavailableo...

(Date:11/23/2009)... NORCROSS,Ga.,Nov.23/PRNewswire-FirstCall/--Immuco...matedinstrument-reagentsystemstothebloodtransfusio...natthePiperJaffray21stAnnualHealthCareConferencein...ast. ,, TheCompany,spresentationisscheduledforT...stothepresentationwillbeavailablethroughthe"AboutU...

(Date:11/23/2009)... CUPERTINO,Calif.,Nov.23/PRNewswire-FirstCall/--DU...ttHogan,ChiefFinancialOfficer,andJoeStauffer,Chief...rJaffrayHealthCareConferenceonTuesday,December1at3...orkPalaceHotelinNewYorkCity. ,, (Logo: http://w..., Toaccessthelivepresentationviatheinternet,plea...

Breaking Medicine Technology:Accuray Incorporated to Present at Piper Jaffray Healthcare Conference and J. P. Morgan Small/Mid Cap Conference 2 DURECT to Present at the 21st Annual Piper Jaffray Health Care Conference 2 GTSI to Spotlight Key Trends in Health IT at its June 17 Technology Leadership Series Seminar 47905 1 GTSI to Spotlight Key Trends in Health IT at its June 17 Technology Leadership Series Seminar 47905 2 GTSI to Spotlight Key Trends in Health IT at its June 17 Technology Leadership Series Seminar 47905 3 Sigma Aldrich Honored With CIO 100 Award for Innovative Web Research Tool Your Favorite Gene powered by Ingenuity 12468 1 Sigma Aldrich Honored With CIO 100 Award for Innovative Web Research Tool Your Favorite Gene powered by Ingenuity 12468 2 Sigma Aldrich Honored With CIO 100 Award for Innovative Web Research Tool Your Favorite Gene powered by Ingenuity 12468 3 Focused Health Solutions Helps Make Preventative Health Screenings Simple and More Affordable 47897 1 Focused Health Solutions Helps Make Preventative Health Screenings Simple and More Affordable 47897 2 Focused Health Solutions Helps Make Preventative Health Screenings Simple and More Affordable 47897 3

[0] Accuray Incorporated to Present at Piper Jaffray Healthcare Conference and J. P. Morgan Small/Mid Cap Conference [0] Immucor to Present at the Piper Jaffray 21st Annual Health Care Conference [0] DURECT to Present at the 21st Annual Piper Jaffray Health Care Conference

Other News:

...n the bright side at least when recovering from a... pessimism are nearly five times more likely to de... study reported in the October issue of Stroke: Jo...sion is common among stroke survivors and can inte...

HHS Secretary Tommy G. Thompson today announced that the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) has awarded two companies contracts designed to spur development of a new anthrax

DALLAS, Oct. 4 Young women with a self-attacking antibody may have an increased stroke risk, according to the first study of its kind published in the October issue of Stroke: Journal of the America

...s yielded a novel way of using a laser to analyze ...to more accurate diagnosis and prescriptive treatm...tional Science Foundation research award, coupled ...create a device that can accurately and simultaneo...

health news:Pessimists more prone to post-stroke depression 2 health news:HHS announces contracts for developing a new anthrax vaccine 2 health news:Antibody may be risk factor for stroke in young women 2

Pessimists more prone to post-stroke depression HHS announces contracts for developing a new anthrax vaccine Antibody may be risk factor for stroke in young women Laser research yields precision breath analysis tool for asthma diagnosis (treatment)

...rliament across all parties should consider health... states an editorial in this week's issue of The L... Blair finally heeded pressure to allow a free vot...exemption of pubs that do not serve food from a sm...

...one fracture resulting from falls increases as we ...have routinely prescribed vitamin D and vitamin Dr...ittle was known about the specific targets of vita...ary 19 in advance of print publication in the Febr...

...a new study indicate that hybrid laboratory antibo...de a potentially safe and effective way to treat t...smallpox vaccination--and possibly may even protec...d by researchers with the National Institute of Al...

...nts taking the commonly prescribed blood thinner w...sis-linked bone fractures, according to a study at...ouis. The results suggest physicians should carefu...the medication and that their patients should take...

health news:Mice studies illustrate potential of chimp/human antibodies to protect against smallpox 2 health news:Mice studies illustrate potential of chimp/human antibodies to protect against smallpox 3 health news:Common blood thinner increases risk of bone fracture 2

MPs should consider health for all when they vote on a smoking ban Vitamin D signals to prevent bone loss during osteoporosis Mice studies illustrate potential of chimp/human antibodies to protect against smallpox Common blood thinner increases risk of bone fracture

Many Medical Screening Tests May Be Un...( ANN ARBOR---Doctors can face an e...),Health