Measures of healthcare quality are of little use to patients

Californian patients deciding where to have surgery cannot rely on published data for information about quality, research in the BMJ has shown.

Researchers looked at all available measures of quality and risk for surgical procedures in California in 1999. Data was available for 21 procedures only 12% of those carried out in the state.

There were no measures of the quality of individual surgeons, and none relating to functional assessments, for example ability to walk after a hip replacement. The length of reporting periods meant that most of the measures reflected care delivered between two and five years ago.

The researchers conclude that the shortage and inadequacy of the data available means that consumers cannot yet choose between providers on the basis of quality.

In a commentary, Professor Martin McKee argues that similar problems apply to the publication of healthcare outcomes in the U.K. The Californian example shows that even with high levels of investment in information technology, the published data can only capture a tiny amount of the overall work of healthcare providers.

There are also problems incorporating quality measures into the system in a way that leads to genuine improvements, he argues. The culture of target-setting in the NHS has already led to examples of providers distorting clinical priorities in order to improve what is reported.

He suggests that healthcare policy makers consider a sign that Einstein kept on his wall: "Not everything that counts can be counted; not everything that can be counted counts."


Contact: Linda Millington
BMJ-British Medical Journal

Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Telemedicine is healthcares new frontier
2. NHS patients not fully engaged with their own healthcare
3. Biopharmaceutical manufacturing efficiencies signal reduced healthcare costs
4. New internet resource facilitates international HIV/AIDS healthcare provider training
5. Why is Ian Kennedys healthcare commission damaging NHS care?
6. Clerks control healthcare access for uninsured patients, study finds
7. For foster children, unstable placements have higher healthcare costs
8. Few disabled kids with psychosocial problems receive mental healthcare
9. Women are displacing men in healthcare services in New Zealand
10. Patient-centered approach just what the doctor ordered for healthcare industry
11. A healthcare software solution to improve follow-up care of patients

Post Your Comments:

(Date:5/30/2020)... (PRWEB) , ... May 29, 2020 , ... In appreciation ... now more than ever, James Hodge Hyundai is offering a $500 bonus towards the ... advantage of this incentive now through January 4, 2021. , To qualify for this ...
(Date:5/28/2020)... ... May 28, 2020 , ... With a growing number ... of student housing are scrambling to implement practices that will help reduce residents’ ... housing beds on 38 campuses across the country, has researched best practices and ...
(Date:5/27/2020)... ... May 27, 2020 , ... ... Pollack, University of Washington Professor of Bioengineering, Founder & Editor of scientific ... & Vapor ( https://www.amazon.com/Fourth-Phase-Water-Beyond-Liquid-ebook/dp/B00N2ASKF2 ) , https://www.voiceamerica.com/episode/123059/the-fourth-phase-of-water , * ...
(Date:5/26/2020)... ... 26, 2020 , ... Sex educator, activist, humanitarian, and Wicked Pictures star ... received the 2020 AASECT Audio Visual Award for jessica drake's Guide to Wicked Sex: ... kind to feature non-actors in its demonstrations and narratives and was produced and distributed ...
(Date:5/21/2020)... ... ... In response to the Coronavirus pandemic, Industrial Magnetics, Inc.(IMI) has developed the ... without using their hands or fingertips. , The new Arm-Pull attaches to ... wrist or elbow when entering or exiting a room. , Perfect for public restrooms, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/30/2020)... ... 29, 2020 , ... HealthyChildren.org, the official parenting website of the American Academy ... . Fourteen lucky winners will receive a $200 Amazon.com* gift card. The contest begins ... once each day during the event. Winners will be drawn on or about June ...
(Date:5/30/2020)... ... May 29, 2020 , ... ... early-phase cancer research, is excited to announce the launch of a new grant ... science and care. , The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in significant disruption ...
(Date:5/30/2020)... ... May 30, 2020 , ... Pregnancy is stressful already, and ... related to COVID-19. Recently, Wellness Expert Jamie Hess teamed with One A Day® ... and postpartum. , A video accompanying this announcement is available at: ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: