HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Misclassification of death may influence perceived value of cancer screening

A statistical analysis of past randomized trials of cancer screening tests suggests that misclassifications in the cause of death may have biased the trial results in favor of screening. The findings appear in the Feb. 6 issue of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute .

Disease-specific mortality is the most widely accepted end point in randomized clinical trials of cancer screening. However, the validity of this end point assumes that the cause of death can be accurately determined. An alternative end point, all-cause mortality, depends only on an accurate determination of deaths and when they occur and, therefore, is unaffected by misclassifications in the cause of death.

To demonstrate that death misclassification may have occurred in past trials, William C. Black, M.D., of Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, and colleagues compared these two mortality end points in 12 randomized studies of cancer screening for which both end points could be determined. These trials involved screening for cancer of the breast, colon, or lung.

In five of the 12 trials, the two mortality end points suggested opposite effects of screening. The authors attributed these discrepancies to two forms of bias that affect the classification of the cause of death.

In one form of bias, deaths from other causes in the screened group are falsely attributed to the target cancer because the cancer was detected by screening. This form of misclassification, called sticky-diagnosis bias, biases the disease-specific mortality results against screening.

In the second form of bias, called slippery-linkage bias, deaths from the screening process or subsequent treatment are falsely attributed to other causes. For example, if an invasive evaluation causes a patient to have a fatal heart attack, the death may be attributed to a heart attack rather than the specific disease being evaluated as a result of the screening test. This form of misclassificat
'"/>

Contact: Linda Wang
jncinews@oup-usa.org
301-594-2927
Journal of the National Cancer Institute
5-Feb-2002


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Misclassification of cause of death in cancer patients
2. New study in Nature demonstrates protection against cell death during heart attack
3. Mouse model reveals potential way to reduce cardiac deaths in kidney patients
4. New estimates for the causes of child deaths worldwide
5. Cardiac deaths peak in sleep hours for patients with sleep apnea
6. Sudan surveys show high rates of death and malnutrition among displaced population
7. Risk of cardiac death after radiotherapy for breast cancer has declined, study finds
8. Study shows risk of cardiac death after radiation for breast cancer has dramatically decreased
9. Neuronal death and processing of Tau protein in Alzheimers disease
10. New guideline tackles leading cause of mother and child death
11. Tobacco industry pays scientists to challenge secondhand smokes link to infant death risk

Post Your Comments:
(Date:5/25/2013)... May 25, 2013 For college ... finals week. Increasingly, they are turning to prescription ... and study. For more on this, go to ... treatment facility, warns that students who pick up ... at risk for developing a physical and psychological ...
(Date:5/25/2013)... 2013 Ayurveda is the traditional ... or wisdom of life". While a medical science, its scope ... of consciousness. Its fundamental philosophy is that disease is the ... It believes that in order to re-establish optimal health, we ... then adopt a life style which brings us back into ...
(Date:5/25/2013)... 2013 The current residents of Back2Basics - ... the B2B staff all came together Saturday, May 18th to ... of Indian Cuisine, the residents got up to thank Roy ... on their road to recovery, and giving them a second ... center in 2010 after realizing the need for a long-term ...
(Date:5/25/2013)... 25, 2013 http://www.resource4thepeople.com/defectivedrugs/Actos-Bladder-Cancer-Lawsuit.html , ... judge's overturning of a jury's award of $6.5 million ... trial* in the country over allegations that the diabetes ... files. , The judge in the case ruled that ... his cancer was caused by the medication.** , Bloomberg ...
(Date:5/25/2013)... 2013 AdvantaClean of Pikes Peak recently ... for a healthy home and business in Colorado Springs ... , mold inspections, mold testing, mold removal , ... coil cleaning. , With over 120 offices nationwide, AdvantaClean ... offering a full suite of services for commercial, institutional, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Addiction and Drug Abuse: Study Drug Adderall Abuse Spikes During Finals 2Health News:Ayurveda Education Programs Offered by the California College of Ayurveda Include Panchakarma Certification, Practitioner Courses, and Body Therapy Classes 2Health News:Back2Basics Drug and Alcohol Rehabilitation Center Celebrates Their 3rd Anniversary 2Health News:Alleged Actos Bladder Cancer Lawsuits Update: $6.5 Million Verdict Overturned as Resource4thePeople Attorneys Continue to Accept Cases 2Health News:Alleged Actos Bladder Cancer Lawsuits Update: $6.5 Million Verdict Overturned as Resource4thePeople Attorneys Continue to Accept Cases 3Health News:Alleged Actos Bladder Cancer Lawsuits Update: $6.5 Million Verdict Overturned as Resource4thePeople Attorneys Continue to Accept Cases 4Health News:Grand Opening! AdvantaClean of Pikes Peak is Proud to Announce Water Damage Restoration, Mold Removal and Air Duct Cleaning Services to the Colorado Springs Area 2Health News:Grand Opening! AdvantaClean of Pikes Peak is Proud to Announce Water Damage Restoration, Mold Removal and Air Duct Cleaning Services to the Colorado Springs Area 3Health News:Grand Opening! AdvantaClean of Pikes Peak is Proud to Announce Water Damage Restoration, Mold Removal and Air Duct Cleaning Services to the Colorado Springs Area 4
(Date:5/23/2013)... 24 de mayo de 2013  Volcano Corporation ... y fabricante de herramientas de precisión para terapia ... de la enfermedad vascular periférica y coronaria, anunció ... Ad enosine V asodilator I ndependent ... la sesión de ensayo clínico hot line late ...
(Date:5/23/2013)... 23, 2013 Nephros, Inc. (OTC Bulletin Board: ... company that develops and sells high performance liquid purification ... offering.  In addition, the concurrent temporary reduction in exercise ... May 17, 2013. Nephros estimates that it ... rights offering.   A portion of the proceeds will be ...
(Date:5/23/2013)... May 23, 2013  TeamHealth Medical Call Center ... and nurse advice lines, announces its newly formed ... nursing and administrative leaders, provides clinical expertise to ... cost-effective services for hospital clients, physician clients and ... system evolves, it,s imperative to continuously advance our ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Volcano anuncia los resultados preliminares del estudio ADVISE II y su inclusión en el ensayo SYNTAX2 2Volcano anuncia los resultados preliminares del estudio ADVISE II y su inclusión en el ensayo SYNTAX2 3Volcano anuncia los resultados preliminares del estudio ADVISE II y su inclusión en el ensayo SYNTAX2 4Volcano anuncia los resultados preliminares del estudio ADVISE II y su inclusión en el ensayo SYNTAX2 5Volcano anuncia los resultados preliminares del estudio ADVISE II y su inclusión en el ensayo SYNTAX2 6Nephros Announces Completion of Rights Offering 2Nephros Announces Completion of Rights Offering 3Nephros Announces Completion of Rights Offering 4TeamHealth Medical Call Center Forms Clinical Advisory Committee 2
Cached News: