HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
People are of 'two minds' on moral judgments

You and your fellow townspeople are hiding in a cellar from marauding soldiers. Your baby starts to cry, which would alert the soldiers to your presence. The only way to save yourself and the others is to smother your baby. What do you do?

Making such tough personal moral judgments involves not just abstract reasoning or emotion, as shown by the results of a new study by Joshua Greene and his colleagues. Rather, their brain scan studies of people making such judgments revealed that the judgments activate brain regions involved in both reason and emotion.

The recruitment of both brain areas could well stem from humans' evolutionary past, they theorize, in which moral judgment is driven in part by social and emotional processing from our ancient primate past in concert with the sophisticated abstract reasoning we have evolved as humans.

In previous studies, the researchers found that when people considered judgments involving others they use brain areas associated with abstract reasoning. Example: You see a runaway trolley headed for five people. You can throw a switch to deflect the trolley onto a track that would kill only one bystander. Should you throw the switch? (Most people say no.)

In contrast, found the researchers, people asked to make personal moral judgments--ones that directly involve them--use brain areas associated with emotional and social cognition. Example: You are standing on a footbridge next to a very large person. You see the same trolley below you. If you throw the person off the footbridge, you save the five people, but personally kill the large person. Should you throw the person off the footbridge? (Most people say no.)

A key question, wondered the researchers, was what happens in the brain when the personal moral dilemmas were difficult, as in the "crying baby" scenario.

In their experiments, Greene and his colleagues presented volunteer subjects with a battery of both easy personal moral dilemmas
'"/>

Contact: Heidi Hardman
hhardman@cell.com
617-397-2879
Cell Press
13-Oct-2004


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. People wounded in tsunami at risk of undetected fungal infections
2. People on food stamps cant afford heart-healthy meals
3. People with low incomes more likely to develop brain tumors
4. People are averse to taking drugs
5. People with chronic eye diseases not getting recommended eye exams
6. People with large pupils can now get LASIK and avoid night vision disturbances
7. People only slightly more likely to die after episodes of stagnant air
8. People with food allergies should not only be careful about what they eat
9. People who give, live longer: U-M study shows
10. People near freeways are exposed to 30 times the concentration of dangerous particles
11. People who dont dip have higher levels of clot factor and risk

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:4/19/2019)... ... ... Residents in long-term-care nursing facilities were prescribed fewer medications when treated by staff ... of U.S. men and women led by the staff at the Los Angeles ... The quality assurance study examined the high number of prescriptions ordered for long-term nursing ...
(Date:4/19/2019)... ... April 19, 2019 , ... The Patient Advocacy Community of ... Health Network-CVPH, Plattsburgh, NY with the 2019 Ruth Ravich Patient Advocacy Award in ... fellow patient advocates. Doyle was honored with the award at The Beryl Institute’s ...
(Date:4/18/2019)... ... 2019 , ... Swiss Pet company PerAnimal launches a new unique ... between human and animal while improving the overall wellness of pet companions. , All ... of experience. They are made by hand from organic Swiss herbal condensate and Swiss ...
(Date:4/18/2019)... Calif. (PRWEB) , ... April 18, 2019 , ... ... upscale dental practice in Beverly Hills that offers a full menu of cosmetic ... cosmetic treatments and sought-after expertise in biomimetic dentistry, which relies on minimally-invasive techniques ...
(Date:4/18/2019)... ... April 18, 2019 , ... WHAT:, Patients today have ... Through the rise of online review sites and healthcare-related searches on the web, ... making important purchasing decisions online. In order to elevate a health system’s reputation ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:4/19/2019)... ... 18, 2019 , ... Janice F. Whaley has a vision. A vision to make organ ... Ms. Whaley has focused her entire career on the mission of all the organ ... donation for transplantation. , There is a sad reality for the individuals who wait for ...
(Date:4/18/2019)... ... , ... MedMen – a cannabis retailer credited with redefining the ... – has partnered with Buxton to identify its most valuable customers and guide site ... tools will allow MedMen to identify their best target markets and strategically plan where ...
(Date:4/18/2019)... (PRWEB) , ... April 18, 2019 , ... ... defining Key Results™, shaping Cultural Beliefs®, and solving Accountability Gaps, and that is ... in the Suntiva team as a service provider to the FDA. This ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: