Prying eyes? Researchers can keep it co...( CHARLOTTESVILLE Va. June 4 -- Patient...),Health

CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va., June 4 -- Patient privacy is a touchstone of medicine. But what about the privacy of those who are responsible for many of the breakthroughs in health careresearchers? Too often the confidentiality of their unfinished work and of the independent experts involved in peer review, which can validate scientific findings, are at risk. It happens when medical journals are hit with subpoenas for documents in a court case. But now, according to a study published in the June 5 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), by University of Virginia researchers, there are important tools researchers and journal editors can use to fight back in today's litigious society.

"It's important because authors and reviewers expect confidentiality during the peer review process. The courts have affirmed that confidentiality, and the frank and open discussion it creates, can be protected," said Dr. David Bruns, professor of pathology at the University of Virginia Health System and co-author of the paper. "Peer review is what leads to the reports that we all rely on."

Confidentiality is key because it can keep corporate power and pressure from tainting peer review. A paper, for instance, may unveil a cheap, effective cancer treatment, angering a pharmaceutical company that sells a more expensive treatment, Bruns said. The company can go to court to find the identities of the reviewers of the paper and publicly criticize their approval of the published study to try and keep the new, cheaper treatment off the market.

Authors and reviewers, therefore, need to know that their research, which is not final, cannot be seen before publication. "We do not want this system impaired," Bruns said.

Co-author Debra Parrish, a Pittsburgh, Pa. attorney, said receiving a subpoena often makes researchers feel they've done something wrong. She points out that "a lot of journals don't realize there are options to stop the onslaught a
'"/>

Contact: Marguerite Beck
mkb8f@virginia.edu
434-924-5679
University of Virginia Health System
4-Jun-2002

Page: 1 2
Related medicine news :

1. Researchers search for first sign of congestive heart failure
2. Researchers say breast cancer in Africa may provide clues to the disease in African-Americans
3. Researchers close in on breast cancer vaccine
4. Researchers discover link between insulin and Alzheimers
5. Researchers model brains electrical storm during a seizure
6. Researchers track programs success in curbing aggressive behavior
7. Researchers confirm Vioxx nearly doubled cardiovascular risks in cancer prevention study
8. Researchers offer emergency workers a lifeline
9. Researchers discover genetic variant that may explain why women develop M.S. more than men
10. Researchers map the sexual network of an entire high school
11. Researchers hope monkeys can provide new insights into depression