HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Anaesthetists need urgent guidance on patients who don't want to be resuscitated

UK anaesthetists could face accusations of euthanasia or assisted suicide if they follow Do Not Attempt Resuscitation (DNAR) Orders during surgery, according to an editorial in the July issue of Anaesthesia.

Patients who have surgery often need routine interventions during anaesthesia that could be classed as resuscitation, points out Consultant Anaesthetist Dr Michael McBrien from the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast, Northern Ireland.

But automatically suspending DNAR Orders during surgery is no longer an acceptable option, according to Dr McBrien and his editorial co-author, Dr Gary Heyburn, Associate Specialist Orthogeriatrician at the Hospital.

"If the anaesthetist were to proceed and strictly obey the general understanding of a DNAR order under such circumstances, it could possibly be construed as an act of euthanasia or assisted suicide" they stress.

McBrien and Heyburn say that UK clinicians urgently need national guidance on how to manage the growing number of DNAR orders, pointing out that American guidelines have been in place since 1993.

"It is surprising that no guidelines or serious discussions on this matter have appeared in the UK to parallel the developments in North America" adds Dr McBrien.

The need for guidelines has been given added impetus by the fact that the Mental Capacity Act is due to come into force next year and that the European Convention on Human Rights is now enshrined in UK Law.

From 1 April 2007, the Act will give formal legal recognition to the patient's right to make advance decisions about the care they receive and reinforce the common law position about DNAR Orders that already exists.

"The paternalistic primary ethical principal of the past, namely immediate medical benefit to the patient, has been overtaken" says Dr McBrien.

"If we are not to face litigation in the future we must read, understand and implement what the law requires from
'"/>

Contact: Annette Whibley
wordwizard@clara.co.uk
Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
28-Jun-2006


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Experts call for urgent research into anti-epileptic drugs given to children
2. Disadvantaged TB patients urgently need social support to make medical treatment more effective
3. Humanitarian response urgently needed to address Lebanese health crisis
4. World Hypertension League calls for urgent action to get more hypertensive patients to goal
5. Doctors call for urgent review of cancer initiative
6. UK liver services need urgent improvement
7. National Service Framework for heart failure urgently needed
8. Research urgently needed to treat blood clots in children
9. Urgent need for guidance on mobile phone use in clinical care
10. Menopausal women dont get enough guidance on treatment options, Stanford survey shows
11. The ESC releases guidance document on Cardiac Rhythm Management product performance

Post Your Comments:
(Date:4/25/2015)... D.C. (PRWEB) April 25, 2015 The ... Bangladesh Worker Safety issues the following statement following the ... earthquake hit Kathmandu, Nepal, resulting in the deaths of ... massive earthquake were felt across Nepal, Bangladesh, India and ... offer my heartfelt condolences to the people of Nepal ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... York, NY (PRWEB) April 25, 2015 By ... technology and data for the enterprise relying on their judgement ... running smoothly. But according to an article published ... can many times actually be doing a disservice to their ... i’s are dotted and t’s are crossed when it comes ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... Parker and Sons projects growth in 2015. The demand ... alongside the growing economy. As a result, Parker and Sons ... help account for the rising need for heating, cooling, and ... we are enthusiastic about. It means growth for us, and ... and Sons. , Indeed, Parker and Sons has been contributing ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... For thirteen years, the Twin Cities DI ... event in the nation! This year, on May 5th, 2015, ... to take DI Day on the road by supporting the ... ChFC, RHU, DIA, CLTC, Chief Executive Officer at Secura Consultants ... the change by stating, "The first Twin Cities DI Day ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... As the nation recognizes the Month ... of these young men and women, the “Alaska – ... their Families” presents a special training session on Adverse ... a better understanding of the effect of childhood trauma ... – civilian and military – who provide services and ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:An Outsider’s Perspective on Cyber Security Can Only Benefit CIOs 2Health News:An Outsider’s Perspective on Cyber Security Can Only Benefit CIOs 3Health News:An Outsider’s Perspective on Cyber Security Can Only Benefit CIOs 4Health News:An Outsider’s Perspective on Cyber Security Can Only Benefit CIOs 5Health News:Parker and Sons Plans to Expand in 2015 2Health News:Secura Consultants Takes DI Day On The Road 2Health News:Coalition Presents Resiliency Training to Raise Awareness during Month of the Military Child (#MOTMC2015) 2
(Date:4/24/2015)... DUBLIN , April 24, 2015  Perrigo Company ... announced its rejection of the unsolicited offer from Mylan ... of the outstanding shares of Perrigo for $60.00 per ... each ordinary Perrigo share (the "Offer").  ... $205.00 per share significantly undervalued the Company and its ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015  A new study shows ... costs of drugs used to slow the progression of multiple ... study led by researchers at Oregon Health & Science University ... increase in the number of MS drugs in the marketplace ... lower or stabilized costs for patients who use those drugs. ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... 24, 2015 In today,s ever-changing and ... around the world to access diverse skill sets, ... there are many areas to misstep in the ... best practices are necessary and beneficial in order ... According to research by benchmarking firm, Best Practices, ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Perrigo Rejects Mylan Unsolicited Offer 2Perrigo Rejects Mylan Unsolicited Offer 3Perrigo Rejects Mylan Unsolicited Offer 4Researchers find alarming rise in cost of MS drugs over past two decades 2Researchers find alarming rise in cost of MS drugs over past two decades 3Researchers find alarming rise in cost of MS drugs over past two decades 4Work Around the Clock: Building Effective Global Capabilities 2
Cached News: