BMJ highlights lack of international cooperation to investigate scientific fraud

This week, the BMJ expresses concern about the validity of a paper it published in 1992 written by Dr Ram B Singh of Moradabad, India.

We also highlight the case of another author, R K Chandra, who had a study retracted by the journal Nutrition earlier this year. As with Singh, serious doubts now hang over the rest of his work.

The stories of Singh and Chandra have been told to highlight the problems associated with investigating allegations of research fraud and to challenge the international scientific community to take action where necessary.

In 1992, the BMJ published a paper by Dr Singh on the protective effects of diet on the heart. But doubts were soon raised about this study and subsequent manuscripts submitted by the same author.

In the absence of answers from the author, Richard Smith, then editor of the BMJ, tried to find an authority in India that would investigate and resolve the doubts over Singh's work, but no institution would take on the task. A statistical analysis of one of Singh's papers, also published in this week's issue, concludes that data "were either fabricated or falsified."

After several years of fruitless correspondence, the BMJ decided it had no option but to publish an account of the suspicions and the failed attempts to have them resolved.

Richard Smith, who left the BMJ in 2004, accepts that it has taken far too long to bring the case of Dr Singh to light, and admits that "the failure is in part mine." However, he adds that "the bigger shame lies with the scientific community that lacks means to investigate these international scandals and has to leave it to an individual journal."

He resolutely stands by the decision to publish the saga, and believes that the scientific community has an obligation to the public to do better.

But once the validity of one study is called into question, who should investigate the rest of the author's work and, if necessary, mete out pun

Contact: Emma Dickinson
BMJ-British Medical Journal

Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Research highlights from Thoracic Society Conference
2. SCAI highlights study using wireless technology to speed care of heart attack patients
3. SCAI Founders Lecture highlights remarkable progress in catheter-based aortic valve replacement
4. Other highlights in the May 2 JNCI
5. Latest IPCC report highlights need for integrated climate/human behavior models
6. New report highlights aromatase inhibitor side effects
7. Study highlights new and cheaper way to treat heroin addiction
8. Other highlights in the Dec. 6 JNCI
9. Conference session highlights importance of interdisciplinary approach to Earth system science
10. $36.4 billion a year: Cost of HIV/AIDS highlights racial and ethnic disparities
11. Literature review highlights options for self-management of asthma exacerbations

Post Your Comments:

(Date:8/11/2020)... Calif. (PRWEB) , ... August 11, 2020 , ... ... focused on addressing unmet needs in the field of urology, today announced that ... UroLift® Center of Excellence. The designation recognizes that Dr. Delair has achieved a ...
(Date:8/7/2020)... (PRWEB) , ... August 07, 2020 , ... ... (CMS) released the Physician Fee Schedule proposed rule for the 2021 calendar year. ... teams by devaluing the procedures they perform which help return patients suffering from ...
(Date:8/5/2020)... ... August 05, 2020 , ... In ... risen to unprecedented challenges. Regardless of the obstacle - shortages of tests, ventilators ... (PPE) and the cancellation or postponement of all nonessential services - providers across ...
(Date:8/5/2020)... ... 05, 2020 , ... Today, YPO Africa , a global leadership community ... for Africa, announced that they have entered into a unique bilateral alliance. The key ... each other in their African impact efforts, with an initial focus on YPO’s ...
(Date:8/3/2020)... (PRWEB) , ... August 03, 2020 , ... ... today the launch of its newest product, CoverageCoach. The site provides a simple ... and purchase insurance products. The company sees CoverageCoach as an important expansion for ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/7/2020)... ... 07, 2020 , ... Bay State Physical Therapy, Massachusetts' leading ... partnered with Comprehensive Physical Therapy in West Brookfield and Leicester. , ... a strong reputation for providing high-quality clinical care with a patient centered approach. ...
(Date:8/7/2020)... ... August 07, 2020 , ... Aquila Recovery, a ... what intensive outpatient programs are and who they are ideal for. ... many turn to intensive outpatient programs provided by addiction recovery centers. An intensive ...
(Date:8/5/2020)... ... August 04, 2020 , ... Help.org , a trusted ... the Best Rehab Facilities in Akron, Ohio for 2020. The informational guide recognizes the ... , According to recent studies , drug overdose is the leading cause ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: