"Smoking pot may not kill you, but it will kill your mother," says an ad from the Partnership for a Drug-Free America. In the first empirical work to examine both stated intentions and actual behavior, researchers argue that this sort of negative message evoking both fear and guilt is a far more effective deterrent to potentially harmful behavior than positive hopeful or feel-good messages.
"Making people feel good is less important than making people feel accountable when it comes to making wise decisions about self-protection," explain Kirsten A. Passyn (Salisbury University) and Mita Sujan (Tulane University) in the March 2006 issue of the Journal of Consumer Research. "Our work separates intentions from implementation and clarifies the role of emotions in this process."
Whether it involves persuading people to use sunscreen or eat high fiber foods, good intentions can be elicited by a variety of appeals. However, getting people to actually follow through on these intentions and change their behavior requires appeals combining fear and an emotion high in self-accountability, such as regret, guilt or challenge.
"[This research] suggests a new emotion-based approach to encouraging a wide range of health protection behaviors," say Passyn and Sujan. "We illustrate the critical role of emotions in persuasion, especially for translating tendencies into action."
Page: 1 Related medicine news :1
Contact: Suzanne Wu
University of Chicago Press Journals
. Drama can help educate and motivate, research shows2
. Personal fulfillment may motivate adolescents to be physically active3
. Physician assisted suicide and why patients are motivated to seek death4
. Conventional prognostic factors fail to explain better prostate cancer survival in most Asian men5
. Waist-to-hip ratio may better predict cardiovascular risk than body mass index6
. Warfarin better than aspirin at stroke prevention in elderly people with atrial fibrillation7
. Nonsmall cell lung cancer -- chemotherapy before surgery appears better than surgery alone8
. Stroke in nonvascular atrial fibrillation -- anti-coagulants better than anti-platelet therapy9
. Holograms make for better vision tests10
. Parents of chronically ill kids are helped by better access to federal and employer leave11
. Diabetes professionals join forces to identify gaps in diabetes care and better self care