HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Have targets improved performance in the English NHS?

The star rating system for English NHS trusts seems to have improved performance, but systems need to be put in place to minimise gaming and ensure targets are not causing problems elsewhere, warn researchers in this week's BMJ.

Annual performance ratings have been published for NHS trusts in England since 2001. This process of naming and shaming gave each trust a rating from zero to three stars. Although the government has now abandoned star ratings, targets are likely to remain.

But have targets improved performance and what ought to happen in the future, ask professors Gwyn Bevan and Christopher Hood?

The key target for accident and emergency departments was the percentage of patients to be seen within four hours. In 2002, before any target was set, 23% of patients spent over four hours in accident and emergency, but by 2004 only 5.3% stayed that long.

Similarly, reported performance improved greatly after ambulance trusts were star rated on their response times, and hospitals were rated on the number of patients waiting for elective surgery.

Interestingly, after 2003, reported performance improved in other UK countries, dramatically in Wales and Northern Ireland. This suggests that the naming and shaming policy in England put pressure on the NHS in the other countries, say the authors.

But the use of targets results in gaming, they add. For example, extra staff being drafted into accident and emergency departments, operations being cancelled, and patients having to wait in ambulances until staff were confident of meeting the target.

This means that when reported performance meets the targets, nobody knows how genuine the improvements are.

Nobody would want to return to the NHS performance before the introduction of targets, so how can we maximise the social benefits and minimise the costs of a regime of targets with sanctions?

They suggest introducing more uncertainty in the way that perfor
'"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-207-383-6529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
16-Feb-2006


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Nottingham center to help UK to meet its carbon targets
2. Wesley Research Institute study targets pharmacists to help diabetes sufferers
3. New therapeutic targets for neurodegenerative diseases
4. Head and neck cancer vaccine targets proteins to create immune response
5. Tequila raw ingredient being developed into drug-carrier that targets colon diseases
6. Molecular differences between early and advanced melanomas could provide new drug targets
7. DNA computing targets West Nile Virus, other deadly diseases
8. How low should we go? Researchers find no clear evidence for ultra-low cholesterol targets
9. New cell-based targets for treating autoimmune inflammatory diseases
10. NYPD targets black, Hispanic and poor neighborhoods for arrests for smoking marijuana in public
11. Compound in dairy products targets diabetes

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:10/13/2018)... ... 13, 2018 , ... The National Fitness Foundation, the official ... Burley as its new Vice President of Partnerships & Marketing. , ... the mission of the President's Council by generating private sector investments and partnerships ...
(Date:10/11/2018)... ... October 11, 2018 , ... ... The medalists are leading scientists in their fields recognized by DuPont Nutrition & ... and technology relevant to the future of food, nutrition and health. , This ...
(Date:10/11/2018)... ... October 11, 2018 , ... ... quite vulnerable to manipulation,” warns former U.S. Department of Homeland Security deputy assistant ... Vulnerable and How We Can Stop it. , Pointing to the ability of ...
(Date:10/7/2018)... ... October 07, 2018 , ... Guruji ... today’s issues affecting humanity at practical and spiritual levels. Founder of the Trivedi ... program of ‘Special Prayers’, inspired by Navratri, is a mystical time when Divine ...
(Date:10/6/2018)... ... October 06, 2018 , ... The iaedp™ ... who treat the full spectrum of eating disorders (ED), today welcomed KellerLife Center ... “As with each of our Presidents Council members, it is an honor for ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/16/2018)... ... 16, 2018 , ... Founders of two of the functional ... omega-3 products, Ben Kelly of Algarithm Ingredients and Philip Bromley of Virun Nutra-Biosciences, ... 15. The title of their presentation was “Making Algal Omega-3’s Great Again (O-MAGA)!”, ...
(Date:10/16/2018)... FALLS CHURCH, Va. (PRWEB) , ... October 16, 2018 , ... ... and a major public health problem (1), the American Psychiatric Nurses Association (APNA) has ... patients at risk for suicide safe. Though deaths by suicide in hospital settings are ...
(Date:10/16/2018)... ... 2018 , ... The iaedp™ Foundation, recognized for excellence in ... providers who treat the full spectrum of eating disorder problems, will once again ... at Symposium 2019. The courses are regularly offered in a self-paced, online ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: