Women were kept isolated in small rooms. Their arms were strapped down. Doctors were often methodically cold. And, upon the delivery, babies were swept away to isolation in a nursery. Much of this has changed. But, some would argue, there still remain many vestiges of this "medicalized" approach to childbirth--a paradigm that is being challenged by more natural, drug-free options like home birth, duolas, and midwives. All of these options, argues Craig Thompson, professor of marketing at University of WisconsinMadison, are consumer choices dictated by a complex matrix of risk assessment.
"This study explores how dissident health risk perceptions are culturally constructed in the natural childbirth community, internalized by consumers as a compelling structure of feeling, and enacted through choices that intentionally run counter to orthodox medical risk management norms," explains Thompson in an article in the September 2005 issue of the Journal of Consumer Research.
When consumers perceive themselves as being at risk, they will more likely go with the norm. This especially holds true with regard to health-related choices. But, consumers are growingly uncertain when it comes to making decisions based on heath risks, such as those related to childbirth. Fostering this discussion are dissident groups, who often find dangers in practices that may be commonly considered safe.
Of these, Thompson sought to "analyze the narratives of consumers who have become socialized in the natural childbirth community. This community of reflexive doubt dramatically inverts the orthodox cultural view that a hospital is the safest place to labor." Thompson conducts in-depth interviews with ten couples that utilized natural childbirth means--both in-home and at the hospital. His findings highlight the struggles consumers deal with when approaching childbirth and the risks associated with both natural and "medicalized" childbirth.
"The risks singlPage: 1 2 Related medicine news :1
Contact: Carrie Olivia Adams
University of Chicago Press Journals
. Childhood obesity indicates greater risk of school absenteeism, Penn study reveals2
. Penn study finds pro-death proteins required to regulate healthy immune function3
. New study shows promise in reducing surgical risks associated with surgical bleeding4
. New study counts the economic cost of persistent pain in Australia5
. UCLA researchers awarded $9M contract for study identifiying antibiotic treatment for MRSA6
. Most seniors now have drug coverage, U-M study shows7
. To gain muscle and lose fat, drink milk: study8
. Wheres the beef? Not enough of it is on elders plates, muscle-metabolism study suggests9
. Even older women at high risk have little interest in being tested for HIV, study finds10
. Metabolic study in mice could lead to good cholesterol boosters11
. Michigan-CDC study supports value of social restrictions during influenza pandemics