In a paper presented at the 2006 Society for Academic Emergency Medicine Annual Meeting, May 18-21, 2006 in San Francisco, researchers from William Beaumont Hospital and Wayne State University described a rapid protocol to evaluate TIA patients.
While there is consensus for rapid CT brain imaging, there is not agreement about the timing of other tests, such as carotid imaging. There is some interest in the use of an Accelerated Diagnostic Protocol (ADP), coupled with an Emergency Department Observational Unit, to avoid the average 3-day stay for admitted patients. This protocol may lower costs and reduce hospital stays, but questions remain about the outcomes and overall quality of care that such patients receive.
To address these and other questions, a controlled trial was conducted at Beaumont Hospital, Royal Oak, Michigan. After an initial evaluation and diagnosis of TIA, 149 patients were randomly assigned to the ADP group or to an inpatient hospital bed. All patients received the same 4 diagnostic tests (Carotid imaging, echocardiogram, cardiac monitoring, and serial clinical evaluation) but those in the ADP group received those tests more rapidly.
The median length of stay for the ADP group was 25 hours vs. 61 hours for the admitted patients, and their 90-day costs were $890 vs. $1547. Approximately 15% of the ADP patients were admitted and their length of stay averaged 100 hours with costs of $2737. While these cost savings are substantial, th