HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Search for cancer genes unlikely to succeed, say experts

The hunt to find common genes that are associated with cancer is unlikely to be successful, say experts in this week's BMJ.

Huge resources are being invested in the search for common inherited genetic variants that increase susceptibility to cancer. One US project, for example, will cost $14m. But devoting a large research effort to searching for common cancer susceptibility genes has several problems, write authors Stuart Baker and Jaakko Kaprio.

The first is that recent research suggests these genes are unlikely to exist or, if they do, are unlikely to have much of an effect on the incidence of cancer.

A second reason to play down the role of common susceptibility genes is studies suggesting that environmental, dietary, or lifestyle changes have a large effect on the incidence of cancer. These studies show changes in incidence within one or two generations, which is probably too quick to be related to the introduction of new genes.

A final reason to be sceptical comes from results from a study of cancers in twins. By analysing data from identical and non-identical twins, the authors showed that genetic susceptibility made only a small to moderate contribution to the incidence of cancer.

Studies that have shown links between common genes and cancer may be due to bias.

But, even if susceptibility genes were identified, showing clinical benefit would still be difficult, and further large trials would be needed, they add.

"The search for common cancer susceptibility genes faces important methodological and practical challenges for cancer prevention, given the small chance that such genetic variants exist and the difficulty and expense of proving substantial clinical benefit if they do exist," they conclude. "Enthusiasm for this new field of research should not precipitate unwarranted expectations."


'"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-020-738-36529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
11-May-2006


Page: 1

Related medicine news :

1. Search for bipolar gene, toll of disease topics of conference call briefings June 16, 17
2. Conventional prognostic factors fail to explain better prostate cancer survival in most Asian men
3. Survival differences by race most apparent in advanced stages of breast cancer
4. Stomach cancer rate set to fall further 25 percent over next decade
5. MRI finds breast cancer before it becomes dangerous
6. Investigators uncover intriguing clues to why persistent acid reflux sometimes turns into cancer
7. New cause of tamoxifen resistance in breast cancer cells discovered at Lombardi
8. Pathway links inflammation, angiogenesis and breast cancer
9. Using MRI for diagnosis could help prevent breast cancer progression
10. Electric fields have potential as a cancer treatment
11. Shining light on pancreatic cancer

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Search for cancer genes unlikely succeed say experts

(Date:4/23/2014)... identified an important enzyme pathway that helps prevent new ... a condition that has been directly linked to cancer ... biochemistry, found that near the end of cell division, ... any breaks in DNA are fully repaired before the ... cells. This process helps safeguard against some of the ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... and accessible detection methods that can rapidly screen ... a single cell inside that population has been ... Lu. , In the Royal Society of Chemistry ... that he and his coworkers have developed a ... a protein ( Chem. Sci. , 2014, DOI: ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... April 21, 2014 Five for-profit and non-profit ... $1.25 million in Proof of Concept grants to ... into commercial products, the Life Sciences Discovery Fund ... Entrepreneur Mentoring Program grant to the Washington Biotechnology ... advisory network to train the next generation of ...
(Date:4/23/2014)... known as Ritalin, may prevent the depletion of self-control, ... a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. , ... or trying to focus attention on a boring textbook ... potential explanation for this difficulty: Exerting self-control for a ... self-control effectively on subsequent tasks. , "It is as ...
(Date:4/22/2014)... A recently FDA-approved device has been shown to ... much as 50 percent. When coupled with an innovative ... the device facilitated the complete elimination of seizures in ... the decade-long clinical trials. , That,s good news for ... the U.S. living with epilepsy whose seizures can,t be ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Study identifies enzymes that help fix cancer-causing DNA defects 2Health News:Following a protein's travel inside cells is key to improving patient monitoring, drug development 2Health News:LSDF announces commercialization grants and Entrepreneur Mentoring Program 2Health News:ADHD drug may help preserve our self-control resources 2Health News:Newly approved brain stimulator offers hope for individuals with uncontrolled epilepsy 2
(Date:1/14/2014)... , Jan. 14, 2014 /PRNewswire-iReach/ -- Acumed,s new SLIC ... guide with accompanying instrumentation to place and insert the ... the soft tissue (e.g. ligament) repair or reconstruction as ... heals. (Photo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20140114/MN45636 ) ...
(Date:1/14/2014)... Jan. 14, 2014 NineSigma , Inc., the ... Innovation Leadership Summit , May 14-16, 2014 at ... Cleveland Ohio . This is ... committed to breakthrough achievements through open innovation. Participants will ...
(Date:1/14/2014)... Md. , Jan. 14, 2014   Evidera , ... industry, announced that the Center for Drug Evaluation and ... its first draft qualification guidance document for a patient-reported ... Exacerbations of Chronic Pulmonary Disease Tool [EXACT] for Measurement ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Acumed introduces the Scapho-Lunate Inter Carpal (SLIC) Screw System 2Acumed introduces the Scapho-Lunate Inter Carpal (SLIC) Screw System 3Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 2Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 3Expect the Unexpected from Leading Global Innovators at NineSigma Leadership Summit, Sharing Winning Strategies to Advance Innovation 4Evidera Announces Release of FDA Draft Guidance on Use of the "EXACT" to Measure Symptoms of COPD Exacerbations 2Evidera Announces Release of FDA Draft Guidance on Use of the "EXACT" to Measure Symptoms of COPD Exacerbations 3Evidera Announces Release of FDA Draft Guidance on Use of the "EXACT" to Measure Symptoms of COPD Exacerbations 4
Cached News: