'Senseless' turf battles between health development and relief agencies

Health development agencies are contributing to the status quo of insufficient public health budgets in poor countries, argues Gorick Ooms, Executive Director of the Belgian section of the medical relief agency Mdecins Sans Frontires.

In a provocative Essay in PLoS Medicine, Ooms argues that "development agencies want their interventions to be sustainable." In other words, the country that is receiving health development agency support (the "host country") must have sufficient funding generated from the country's own resources to support these interventions.

But public health budgets in the world's poorest countries, says Ooms, are inadequate and increasing these budgets requires stronger national and international financial commitments. If public health budgets were increased, the level of health care within the capacity of the host countries would be higher.

"Health development advocates assume that public health budgets will not be increased," says Ooms, "and base their sustainability estimations on this assumption. In doing so, they contribute to the status quo of insufficient public health budgets."

Medical relief organizations, on the other hand, are "not driven by health development approaches," he says, but by "a humanitarian impulse; there are overwhelming needs and there is an obligation to respond to those needs."

The "turf battles" between emergency medical relief agencies and health development agencies are senseless, says Ooms. "Health development advocates should not blame medical relief advocates for ignoring concerns about sustainability. The actions of medical relief agencies have nothing to do with ignorance; they are a deliberate choice. The status quo of insufficient public health budgets deserves only a firm rejection."

Citation: Ooms G (2006) Health development versus medical relief: The illusion versus the irrelevance of sustainability. PLoS Med 3(8): e345.


Contact: Andrew Hyde
Public Library of Science

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. USC law professor battles schizophrenia
2. Comparison of obstetric outcomes between on-call and patients own obstetricians
3. Explaining a link between strokes and Alzheimers
4. Researchers call for investigation into links between khat use and psychiatric disorders
5. Comparison of patients access to new and better cancer drugs reveals inequalities between countries
6. No link found between autism and celiac disease
7. Research demonstrates link between domestic violence and asthma
8. Correlation between bile duct obstruction and ductal cancer found
9. Health gap between social groups widens in later life
10. Molecular differences between early and advanced melanomas could provide new drug targets
11. Queens studies find new links between wine, fermented foods and cancer

Post Your Comments:

(Date:7/23/2019)... ... July 23, 2019 , ... Shady Grove Fertility (SGF) ... grand opening of its newest full-service fertility and in vitro fertilization (IVF) program in ... full-service location offers access to two leading, board certified reproductive endocrinologists, a state-of-the-art laboratory, ...
(Date:7/21/2019)... ... ... Surgical facelifts might be the gold standard for lifting facial skin and ... needs surgery, according to cosmetic surgeon Dr. Richard E. Buckley, medical director of MilfordMD ... who can’t tolerate the downtime associated with a surgical facelift, don’t want surgery or ...
(Date:7/18/2019)... ... July 18, 2019 , ... ... officials in Congress about new bills to protect patients from unexpected out-of-network medical ... People from Surprise Medical Bills Act ( H.R. 3502 ), introduced in the ...
(Date:7/18/2019)... ... July 18, 2019 , ... For the fourth ... Atlanta, Magazine’s list of “Top Doctors” issue. Deutsch is a double-board-certified plastic and, ... With specialized training from MD Anderson Cancer Center and Albert Einstein, Montefiore Medical ...
(Date:7/17/2019)... ... 17, 2019 , ... The FDA has cleared the "truSculpt® flex" ... to eight body areas simultaneously. Dr. Dennis Dass says the truSculpt® flex ... than previous muscle toning devices or conventional exercise. , “The truSculpt® flex is FDA-cleared ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:7/23/2019)... (PRWEB) , ... July 23, 2019 , ... ... its sixth physical rehabilitation hospital in the ever-growing Liberty Township (N. Cincinnati), Ohio ... acres, just north of Cincinnati, Ohio. The hospital site is located at the ...
(Date:7/23/2019)... ... July 23, 2019 , ... Breathe Life , a ... Hill , Partner at Diagram Ventures , has joined its board of directors. ... building and scaling early-stage technology businesses to the Breathe Life board at a time ...
(Date:7/23/2019)... ... July 23, 2019 , ... ... needs in the field of urology, today announced that Samuel Dakil, MD, Norman ... Excellence. The designation recognizes that Dr. Dakil has achieved a high level of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: