HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Should doctors tell patients about expensive, unfunded drugs?

It is unethical and paternalistic for doctors to withhold information from patients about new drugs that are not yet publicly funded, say researchers in this week's BMJ.

New drugs may be more effective than existing treatments, but many are very expensive and may not be available through publicly funded health schemes.

This raises several ethical dilemmas for doctors. Is it reasonable to ask a patient to finance the full cost of their treatment when it is not provided by government? Would it be unethical to raise the option of treatment with an unsubsidised drug?

Researchers surveyed 184 Australian cancer specialists about their opinions and practices regarding potentially useful but unsubsidised drugs.

A large proportion said they would not discuss an expensive drug with a patient if it were not subsidised because of potential psychological and emotional effects that these discussions might have on patients and their families. The survey also found that these discussions were stressful for clinicians.

But the authors argue that this practice fails to respect autonomy and may not be in the patient's best interests. They believe that withholding information on the basis of what a patient would want is "a dangerous medical path to unjustified paternalism."

A further ethical issue concerns the cost of publicly funding newer, expensive treatments, they write. This is an urgent question of distributing limited resources fairly that faces not just new drugs, but many forms of modern technological care. "The gap between what we can do and what we can afford will continue to grow, at a personal and community level."

The issue of accessing new expensive drugs has no easy solution, they say. Nevertheless, it seems unreasonable to withhold information from a patient about any potentially beneficial treatment because of concerns about capacity to pay, even if these discussions cause distress for some patients. '"/>

Contact: Teresa Hagan
thagan@bma.org.uk
44-20-7383-6174
BMJ-British Medical Journal
3-Nov-2005


Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Should adult male circumcision be recommended for HIV prevention in the US?
2. Shoulder tapping -- Young males are most willing to purchase alcohol for underage youth
3. Should NICE evaluate complementary medicine?
4. Should Muslims have faith-based health services?
5. Should smokers be refused surgery?
6. Should patients undergoing surgery get ASA?
7. Should patients have to opt out of electronic records?
8. Assisted dying: Should it be legal?
9. Should older men be screened for prostate cancer?
10. Should we screen people for depression?
11. Should we ban consumer drug ads? - Press release from PLoS Medicine

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:6/28/2020)... ... 26, 2020 , ... Medisend College of Biomedical Engineering Technology, ... training that prepares graduates for professional careers as field service engineers and biomedical ... Trustees. , Ms. Williams currently serves as Associate Vice Chancellor of Workforce and ...
(Date:6/28/2020)... ... ... The secret of surviving a pandemic with one’s sanity intact does not ... was the first product to disappear off the shelves when the COVID-19 crisis began. ... less need to venture out, the longer you can “survive”. However, does all this ...
(Date:6/25/2020)... ... ... Denials Management, Inc. has just published The Health Insurance Appeals Guide to ... of mental health and substance use disorder (MH/SUD) treatment services. It was written by ... the steps in the appeals process. Complimentary copies of the Guide can be ...
(Date:6/24/2020)... ... June 24, 2020 , ... SPH Analytics , ... Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) has successfully deployed SPH’s Population Care™ all-payer population health ... value-based care. Use of Population Care is benefitting more than 77,000 patients covered ...
(Date:6/23/2020)... ... June 23, 2020 , ... Oak Street Health, a network ... further plans for nationwide expansion in 2020 with the company’s first centers in New ... two locations in Brooklyn, N.Y., and a new center in Jackson, Miss. , ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/19/2020)... ... June 19, 2020 , ... ... Trials.' This campaign showcases the innovative medical research achieved through clinical trials ... and disease treatment. This public awareness campaign aims to foster dialogue among ...
(Date:6/19/2020)... (PRWEB) , ... June 19, 2020 , ... ... provider, and American Healthcare Staffing Association (AHSA), a pioneer and leader in healthcare ... largest nonprofit Catholic health systems in the United States. AHTG and AHSA are ...
(Date:6/19/2020)... (PRWEB) , ... June 18, 2020 , ... World Allergy ... to emphasize the importance of maintaining regular care of allergies and asthma during the ... the world caused by infection with a new strain of coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2). Patients with ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
Cached News: