HOME >> MEDICINE >> NEWS
Vaccinate or not? Treat or not? Study looks at tricky health decisions

ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- If a deadly bird flu reaches America, which would you choose: Would you get a risky experimental vaccine now, or forego that risk but face an even greater risk of dying in the epidemic? What would you choose for your child? What if you were in charge of public health for your community?

A new study probes how we make such tricky decisions, and how our decisions might change dramatically if we step back and put ourselves in the shoes of others.

The findings may help individuals who face tough health choices, and decision makers who make choices for larger groups. It may also help illuminate situations where individuals make medical decisions that go against the advice from experts and authorities, and help guide doctors in advising patients.

In the June issue of the Journal of General Internal Medicine, a team from the University of Michigan Medical School and the Veterans Affairs Ann Arbor Healthcare System report the results of a medical decision making study involving nearly 2,400 people of all ages and backgrounds who completed extensive online questionnaires.

Study participants were first randomly divided into four groups. People in one group of participants were asked to imagine themselves as patients in two different medical scenarios -- an experimental vaccine against a deadly flu and chemotherapy for a slow-growing cancer -- and asked to choose either to get the medical option or to take their chances without it. Each of the options carried risks and benefits, though the statistically better choice in each scenario was to get the vaccine or chemotherapy.

The remaining three groups of participants also read the same medical scenarios, but they were asked to think about the problem from different perspectives. One group put themselves in the shoes of a doctor advising a patient, another took the role of a parent deciding for a child, and a third group imagined being a medical director of a hospital
'"/>

Contact: Kara Gavin
kegavin@umich.edu
734-764-2220
University of Michigan Health System
31-May-2006


Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Vaccinated adults less likely to die from pneumonia
2. Vaccinate infants of hepatitis B mothers, say experts
3. Treatment for early prostate cancer associated with type of specialist seen
4. Treatment outcomes of patients with HIV and tuberculosis
5. Treating HIV in war zones -- Public health emergencies need rapid advice from WHO
6. Treatment of kidney condition requires an individualized approach
7. Treatment of in-hospital cardiac patients is focus of Jefferson University presentations
8. Treatment for homeless youth pays off in long run, study finds
9. Treating prostate cancer in elderly men associated with longer survival, compared to non-treatment
10. AASM position statement: Treating insomnia with over-the-counter sleep aids, herbal supplements
11. Treatment discovered for deadly childhood disease

Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
TAG: Vaccinate not Treat not Study looks tricky health decisions

(Date:7/22/2014)... Rochelle, NY -- New guidelines on cholesterol treatment and ... double the risk of dying from atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease ... do women with a similar risk profile (based on ... The implications of this finding for when and how ... Editorial in Journal of Men,s Health , a ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... (PRWEB) July 22, 2014 The Beryl ... and third annual Institute Scholar Program. These offerings reinforce ... the patient experience in healthcare and the need for ... The grant and scholar programs are intended ... , Value of focusing on the patient experience ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... The Pennsylvania judge overseeing hundreds ... in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas won’t ... cases alleging the medication caused plaintiffs to develop ... In an Order dated July 18, 2014, Judge ... certify the matter for an immediate appeal to ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... July 22, 2014 The park is ... the Kendalltown Homeowners Association, Inc., made a ... residential community with the purchase of playground equipment from ... located in beautiful Miami Florida, and is a 475-unit ... of the surrounding landscape has created a tropical paradise ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... TUESDAY, July 22, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- One of ... of a psychiatric disorder has uncovered 83 new sites ... The findings, made by an international team of ... variants linked to the disorder to 108. ... used as a test to predict who will or ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:The Beryl Institute Opens Applications for 2014 Patient Experience Grant and Scholar Programs 2Health News:The Beryl Institute Opens Applications for 2014 Patient Experience Grant and Scholar Programs 3Health News:Risperdal Lawsuit News: Pennsylvania Judge Won’t Reconsider Denial of Punitive Damages for Risperdal Gynecomastia Plaintiffs, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 2Health News:Risperdal Lawsuit News: Pennsylvania Judge Won’t Reconsider Denial of Punitive Damages for Risperdal Gynecomastia Plaintiffs, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 3Health News:Risperdal Lawsuit News: Pennsylvania Judge Won’t Reconsider Denial of Punitive Damages for Risperdal Gynecomastia Plaintiffs, Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reports 4Health News:Fun in the Florida Sun: Kendalltown Homeowners Association Inc. Expands Outdoor Recreation with American Parks Company™ 2Health News:Fun in the Florida Sun: Kendalltown Homeowners Association Inc. Expands Outdoor Recreation with American Parks Company™ 3Health News:Gene Discoveries Could Shed New Light on Schizophrenia 2
(Date:7/22/2014)... , July 22, 2014  Decision Resources Group finds ... Canada will remain relatively stagnant at a ... the fact that percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) volumes are growing ... developed markets, such as the United States ... be largely driven by the increase in penetration of PCI ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... 22, 2014 Research and Markets  has ... 2014-2018" report to their offering. ... used to diagnose, monitor, and assess medical conditions, diseases, ... provide outcomes for earlier and more targeted treatment. These ... provide accurate results. This kind of diagnostics provides early ...
(Date:7/22/2014)... VIEW, Calif. , July 22, 2014 /PRNewswire/ ... resonance imaging (MRI) market, Frost & Sullivan recognizes ... for Product Leadership. Siemens Healthcare,s FREEZEit solution, which ... the need for robust and motion-insensitive imaging. The ... boosted the evolution of body MRI imaging in ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:The Canadian Interventional Cardiology Device Market Will Remain Relatively Stagnant Through 2022 at Around $80 Million 2The Canadian Interventional Cardiology Device Market Will Remain Relatively Stagnant Through 2022 at Around $80 Million 3Global IVD Market 2014-2018: Key Vendors are Abbott Laboratories, Johnson & Johnson, Roche Diagnostics and Siemens Healthcare 2Global IVD Market 2014-2018: Key Vendors are Abbott Laboratories, Johnson & Johnson, Roche Diagnostics and Siemens Healthcare 3Frost & Sullivan Recognizes Siemens Healthcare with the Product Leadership Award for Innovative Techniques in Abdominal Imaging 2Frost & Sullivan Recognizes Siemens Healthcare with the Product Leadership Award for Innovative Techniques in Abdominal Imaging 3Frost & Sullivan Recognizes Siemens Healthcare with the Product Leadership Award for Innovative Techniques in Abdominal Imaging 4
Cached News: